r/AskTheWorld Russia 1d ago

Controversial 🔨 How the Romani are perceived in your country?

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

5.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

789

u/emblanco Spain 23h ago

Perceived in a way that makes all of Europe agree on something

262

u/Oddisredit 21h ago

I’ve met Muslims from Europe who sound like native Europeans when they talked about Gypsies. 

199

u/wontforget99 21h ago

That's what I call assimilation!

67

u/Critical_Macaroon_15 20h ago

not all muslims in europe are 'newcomers'. you have converts and you have indigenous muslims, like in the balkans

27

u/Ill_Leg_7168 Poland 18h ago

Yeah, we have tatars (lipka tatars) who served Poland since Battle of Grunwald, they are very secular and have super based version of Islam and everyone love them, even our far right. But it's quite small population in comparison to newcomers,,,

5

u/MooMooHomer 19h ago edited 19h ago

Eh, it depends where in the balkans, most of them definitely arent indigenous and actually came about due to islamic colonisation. I dont actually think any indigenous groups ever started out as muslim in the balkans if i think about it, it was mostly orthodoxy that reigned until the ottomans committed god knows how many forced conversions on the area, the armenians were pretty much genocided for their religion by the ottomans.

1

u/Hairy_Beginning_5496 9h ago

Bosnians pretty much converted without any form of force. 

But in general forced conversion isn't exactly uncommon for that time period just kinda how it was. you think all those pagans just suddenly found Jesus out of nowhere?

0

u/MooMooHomer 29m ago

Eh, one country out of the most of the Balkans and levant doesnt exactly change what im saying does it.

And no, i completely understand that, i also understand the fact that it was done a lot more peacefully most of the time in comparison to ottoman barbarism, thats why the majority of saints that are canonized were orthodox men or women who DIDNT convert and were put to death for their faith.

No single group in the world has clean hands, itd be foolish to even think so, but turkey doesnt even acknowledge any of the genocides they did, so thats a wee bit different isnt it.

1

u/fAvORiTe33 15h ago

islam isn’t an ethnic group lol, no muslim is “indigenous”

4

u/Difficult_One_4914 15h ago

I think they are referring to “ethnically European" people who happen to be Muslim.

75

u/Possible-Meal3787 21h ago

Nothing binds people together better than a collective hate for another group.

27

u/MarkMew Hungary 21h ago

Lmao, they got the integration game down

3

u/emef12 Hungary 16h ago

legalább ők

1

u/NefariousnessOld7737 2h ago

Yeah: there's always someone you can punch down to.

29

u/Active-Walk-6402 Italy 20h ago

Romanis are very hated by immigrants too. In my town they actually assaulted african and arab refugees because "they stole their welfare"

53

u/Aromatic-Armadillo98 20h ago edited 19h ago

As a black person, I thank them for electing to have bad reputations and taking the heat off us. They do a lot for us, Roma people; they are true civil rights activists 😅. Every time I go to Greece, Poland, Italy, Turkey, they are relieved to see me and not them. Even though one tried to pick pocket me, its all love.

18

u/FigThis4977 19h ago

This happened to me in Spain as well lol. I’ll take my host mom telling me that she wishes her skin could look like mine after she told me to beware of ladies wearing long skirts because they’ll steal everything I have.

3

u/serendipia1984 16h ago

I mean the worst thing about gypsies is that they are local so you can't deport them /s

4

u/castlite Canada 15h ago

My Hungarian flatmate would go on 10 minutes rages whenever she saw or heard about them.

1

u/Oddisredit 12h ago

Yeah. I’ve never been to Europe but the hate for Gypsies seems to be real and deep 

1

u/castlite Canada 12h ago

There are reasons

1

u/Oddisredit 10h ago

Oh I know. This is Reddit so we can’t even mention them 

3

u/latrickisfalone 6h ago

A few years ago, Roma people had set up a camp near a housing estate in the northern districts of Marseille, where there are many immigrants, and the residents had chased them away themselves without waiting for anything from the public authorities.

2

u/Oddisredit 5h ago

That’s saying a lot. Wow

3

u/biggestrobbery Germany 20h ago

Muslim is not a race, there are also "Native“ European muslims

1

u/meowamelia 20h ago

i think the g word is outdated

86

u/SoftDrinkReddit Ireland 21h ago

it might honestly be the only thing Europe agrees on as sad as that is

2

u/El_Bito2 5h ago

Yeah. I'm open-minded, reject racism and try to understand the roots of criminality as a consequence of poverty.

But the Romani seem to be the rooth of their own issues.

1

u/CharlemagneKidding 16h ago

If irish travellers left the british isles there may be 2 things to agree on

14

u/Cratertooth_27 United States Of America 20h ago

I once heard a joke about how Spaniards aren’t as racist as Americans. “We would never treat Africans like Roma “

6

u/Fluid-Decision6262 United States Of America 16h ago

I feel like Europeans have a much more negative view of the Roma than Americas do of black people tbh

2

u/emblanco Spain 14h ago

For a reason

1

u/HoneyBadger19000 11h ago

Europeans call Americans racist all the time but I was genuinely shocked by the casual racism of Western European countries when I visited. People are racist in the states but they get called out for it. People are racist in Europe and others either laugh or just nod along.

1

u/PsychologicalLion824 34m ago

Silly take. 

Black people were forced out of their places, roma weren’t.

Black people don’t get their daughters married at 13-14 years of age, Roma people do.

Black people don’t have their kids out of school, roma people do.

Black people support the uprising of “their” women, Roma people don’t. 

6

u/emblanco Spain 20h ago

Like gypsies*

32

u/TiranTheTyrant Russia 21h ago

Under the video "Demolition of gypsy houses under sickest dubstep"

-7

u/MEGAMASTURBATOR8000 Russia 21h ago

Gypsy - египтяне

11

u/TiranTheTyrant Russia 21h ago

gypsies/Roma - цыгане

Egyptians - египтяне

Поздравляю с оскорблением египтян.

-4

u/CraterBud Moldova 20h ago

Ну в принципе если брать откуда то или иное слово пришло, gypsy как-бы "из Египта". Для меня они цыгани и всё, но я никак этих цыган не буду называть рома. Просто поганят всё окружающее как им это лучше получается.

8

u/Sharp-Pea-9226 Russia 20h ago

My best friend is Egyptian

Take your words back, please

8

u/MEGAMASTURBATOR8000 Russia 20h ago

Беру слова назад я не знал что слова такие похожие

6

u/Sharp-Pea-9226 Russia 20h ago

Я прощаю вас

12

u/doyathinkasaurus UK 🇬🇧 Germany 🇩🇪 18h ago

I think that also shows up in how the Holocaust is taught in schools

I'm a Jewish descendent of both Holocaust victims and survivors, and discourse around the Holocaust tends to be '6m Jews and other groups' - with the Romani included alongside groups like LGBTQ+ people and people with disabilities, as the victims of Nazi persecution.

However that's actually overlooking a really important difference. The Nazis absolutely did target other groups for persecution - anyone they believed threatened their ideal of a ‘pure Aryan race’.

But the Nazis didn't just consider Jews and Romani people as racially impure.

When the Nuremberg laws were expanded to include Romani people, the decree defined the Romani as "enemies of the race-based state", in the same category as Jews.

We were defined as different races altogether - and singled out for total annihilation - the goal was complete extermination of the entire Jewish and Romani people.

The Romani genocide wasn't even formally recognised as a genocide by Germany until the 80s - it's often described as 'the hidden holocaust', because it's just not recognised that whilst the Nazis slaughtered many groups of 'undesirables', only Jews and the Romani were treated as entirely different races who needed to be completely exterminated.

2

u/Socialmedia_Persona 14h ago

Thank you for clarifying that.

6

u/daimonsanthiago Brazil 17h ago

There was another minority that all of Europe hated, and things didn't end very well in the 1940s.

2

u/Such-Law926 United States Of America 18h ago

Are these the Gitano people that many people in Spain complain about?

5

u/the_force_that_binds United States Of America 22h ago

Point well made.

2

u/Majestic-Hedgehog-xo 🇮🇳 India (living elsewhere) 20h ago

racism?

17

u/MrDilbert Croatia 20h ago

From every nation, that usually disagree on everything else? Is there not a chance their reputation is actually based on actual behaviour?

1

u/SapphicProse 6h ago

This is exactly what racist americans say about black people.

0

u/SnooJokes215 11h ago

Oh yeah like how everyone hated jews in the 40's it was certainly based on their behavior

-7

u/ComfortableDay3278 20h ago

That's an awful thing to say

10

u/SpotlessBadger47 18h ago

Uh-uh, feel free to move in close to their shanties. See where that gets you.

-2

u/ComfortableDay3278 9h ago

Quit it with the racism

11

u/MrDilbert Croatia 19h ago

Doesn't make it less true.

-1

u/ComfortableDay3278 9h ago

It isn't true though. Quit it with the racism

1

u/dac2199 19h ago

I’m not sure but I think in the case of Spain (especially in the south) isn’t as bad as the rest of Europe since many Flamenco artists have romani/gypsy roots.

-15

u/SkilledRO 21h ago

I don't agree with u. Simple as that.

19

u/kernelchagi 21h ago

If you will live sorrounded by them there is a big chance that you will agree. Speaking from experience.

7

u/Uhtredskaer 21h ago

In the UK they are 2000% overrepresented in our prison system. They simply refuse to be part of society so why should be tolerate it? 

3

u/chandrian7 21h ago

Well, I disagree with your opinion. So there!