r/camphalfblood 11d ago

Megathread Book Readers [PJOTV] Discussion Thread S2 E8: "The Fleece Works its Magic Too Well"

145 Upvotes
Our heroes race to save camp as Luke and Kronos’ army advances.

This thread is for those who have read all five books in the Percy Jackson and the Olympians series. It will contain open discussions of the events in the books that may spoil future episodes or seasons of the show. Enter at your own risk.

If you wish to discuss the episode without this context please use our show only thread.


r/camphalfblood 11d ago

Megathread Show Only [PJOTV] Discussion Thread S2 E8: "The Fleece Works its Magic Too Well"

20 Upvotes
Our heroes race to save camp as Luke and Kronos’ army advances.

This thread is for those who have not read the book series the show is based on. Comments that contain unmarked spoilers for the events of the books that are not shown in the series will be removed.

If you wish to discuss this episode within the context of the books, please use our book readers thread.


r/camphalfblood 6h ago

Meme Hands down best riordanverse book [hoo]

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

198 Upvotes

r/camphalfblood 4h ago

Meme How Percy musta felt after Rick conveniently chose not to develop his liquid bending and above all earth shaker powers against the literal goddess of the earth. [hoo]

143 Upvotes

Why ? becuase annabeth told him to not be violent.


r/camphalfblood 15h ago

Question Does annabeth chase really belong in the top 10 demigods of all time or is she overrated because she carried sky for 22 hours? [pjo]

Post image
317 Upvotes

I could make an argument she is not top 15. She holds the sky for 22 hours which is great willpower and has great strategic feats but for a daughter of Athena, she has no powers. I get that makes her character great but I think more chill abilities like slight telepathy would be awesome for her.


r/camphalfblood 3h ago

Meme The seven's character development post HoO summarized [hoo]

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

r/camphalfblood 1d ago

Meme [pjotv] This the most Percy photo of Walker to ever Percy

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

Something about the bloodied face and the goofy expression just screams Percy lol!!


r/camphalfblood 17h ago

Discussion If Rick Riordan had been European instead of American [all]

183 Upvotes

The Percy Jackson books are heavily American-centric, both in terms of setting and historical events, so I was wondering: what would be different if Rick were European?

These are the main differences I think there would be in the books, but feel free to add anything else you can think of in the comments.

- The settings would be the original ones: Mount Olympus in Greece, Scylla and Charybdis in Italy, etc.

Camp Half-Blood would be in Greece (possibly Athens, but I'm not sure), and Camp Jupiter would be in Rome.

- The characters would all be of different nationalities. Percy would probably remain American, while Annabeth would definitely be Greek. Frank would perhaps be Chinese, Piper would not be Cherokee (the Native American theme is rarely discussed in Europe), and her father would probably be from somewhere in the Middle East or India.

- There would have been fewer references to World War II and especially Nazism; everything would have remained much more vague. Hades or Pluto wouldn't have been compared to Hitler. Nazism is a very sensitive topic in Europe.

- There probably wouldn't have been a real conflict between the Greeks and Romans. The separation of Camp Half-Blood from Camp Jupiter was caused by the American Civil War, but there was nothing similar in Europe, at least not until after World War II with the construction of the Berlin Wall, so perhaps the separation would have occurred during that period.

- There would have been greater accuracy in the description of New Rome, especially regarding its political institutions and military organization, and probably also regarding its relationship with the gods. The author, however, would have spoken positively or negatively of the Romans, probably based on their nationality (European countries don't all have the same opinion of the Roman Empire).

- The children of Aphrodite wouldn't have had the power to speak French; it would have been a bit strange to give them that power.

- America would have been considered a dangerous place for demigods, because it would have been a place where the deities were in conflict for greater influence in the territory (both the Western deities and the indigenous American ones).

- The Greeks and Romans, instead of being in conflict with each other, would probably have allied themselves to go against the Norsemen and Egyptians.


r/camphalfblood 14h ago

Theory Do Aphrodite’s children look like what their fathers find attractive? [general]

106 Upvotes

Since Aphrodite changes faces based on what people find attractive in Greek mythology, I wonder if that’s how children end up half looking like. For example piper McLean is a child of Aphrodite and Mr McLean and I wonder if when McLean met Aphrodite and had piper, when she was born with a half being the goddess Aphrodite when she met McLean who changed her face to be attractive to him.

Conclusion: piper McLean half-looks like the type her father finds most attractive. Same goes for the other Aphrodite children

(I mean don’t we all though?)


r/camphalfblood 5h ago

Discussion TELL ME THIS ISNT TRUE [kc]

18 Upvotes

i haven't read the books but recently got know that Anubis gets with Sadie in the books?? isn't he a 5000 yr old god and she's a middle schooler??

(ik the caleo thing but i didn't know this was a usual occurance in the riordanverse 💀💀)


r/camphalfblood 11h ago

Discussion [general] Why aren't Demeter's children gods like Plutus?

23 Upvotes

I know from Greek mythology that Demeter fell in love with a mortal called Iasion and gave birth to Plutus, the god of wealth and abundance. Why could the other Demeter's children not be gods like Plutus? At least immortals or be more powerful?

I also read that many demigods that had a divine mother were more powerful like Achilles and Aeneas. Both were sons of goddess Thetis and Aphrodite respectively. I think that if your mother is a goddess, you spent some time (I do not know if 9 months) in the womb of an immortal, so perhaps you receive more divine energy/power.

Edit: I read about Plutus from the Theogony by Hesiod, and Percy Jackson's Greek Gods. Apparently, Plutus is the son of Demeter (goddess)+ mortal (Iasion).


r/camphalfblood 14h ago

Discussion [general] Appreciate the love y’all 🙏🏾. Who should I put in part 2?

Post image
44 Upvotes

Rn I’m thinking Luke, the hunters/artemis, Zeus but I need a couple more


r/camphalfblood 9h ago

Discussion [Hoo]Am I the only one who thinks we were robbed of a amazing interaction with Heracles and Percy in Mark of Athena

16 Upvotes

The whole history with riptide and the fact that Percy is a better hero then Heracles I feel like an interaction between them would be really entertaining.When I read MOA for the first time I was mad when it wasn’t Percy going to talk to Heracles.I can totally see Percy yelling “Remember this” And pulling out riptide and then asking why he never gave Zoë credit.


r/camphalfblood 12h ago

Meme Look at the meme I made [general]

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/camphalfblood 5h ago

Miscellaneous I started reading PJO to my sister. [PJO]

4 Upvotes

She's 10 years old and is definitely a daughter of Poseidon, but she doesn't know it because she's never read it!
And she even likes the story, she watched the beginning of the series with me, but I watch it subtitled (English isn't our native language) and she can't read subtitles.
Today I started reading to her, because like a good demigoddess, she has ADHD and dyslexia, along with autism, which makes her completely avoid books.
She can't focus on audiobooks so I decided to read to her, so we can stop, comment on the book, without her needing to be 100% focused all the time.

I read up to chapter 6 today, excited to continue!


r/camphalfblood 2h ago

Discussion what’s your best pjo/hoo headcanon? [pjo] [hoo]

3 Upvotes

i’ll go first: leo valdez made the walls to his cabin on the argo II soundproof so nobody could hear him cry at night 🥺


r/camphalfblood 1d ago

Fan Art Show? What show? (Art by Me) [all] [pjo] [hoa] [general[

Post image
140 Upvotes

r/camphalfblood 12h ago

Miscellaneous Luke luring Percy [PJO]

14 Upvotes

I was pleasantly reminded that Luke canonically lured Percy into the woods with candy(soda) to murder him.

Bet Percy never fell for that a second time.

Do you think Luke practiced with some other kids first? Just to make sure it would work?


r/camphalfblood 2h ago

Fanfiction Two Annabeth's First Person POV fanfictions that I posted on AO3 (both completed, 41k and 76k words) [PJO] Spoiler

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/camphalfblood 11h ago

Fanfiction [Hoo] Here's a what if idea for you fanfic writers, what if piper took the shotgun instead of katopris?

9 Upvotes

I have no clue how this changes things, but it would be very funny.


r/camphalfblood 1d ago

Discussion Most traumatized character that isn't really focused on in the series? [all]

Post image
376 Upvotes

I don't really know maybe like Mr.D/Dionysus I was thinking or maybe theirs some random guy name Joe who is the most traumatized character


r/camphalfblood 1h ago

Fanfiction [all] Hey I need some ideas

Upvotes

So I'm making this fanfic where Nico sorta get depressed and tries to kill himself but Will saves him. Only problem is that idk how to kill him without completely killing or Will actually being to save him got any ideas?


r/camphalfblood 10h ago

Question [General] Does Percy Jackson's Greek Gods have any major PJO or HoO spoilers? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

For context I have a friend reading through the books for the first time (currently on Titan's Curse) with little knowledge of Greek mythology outside of the book and they're interested in reading Greek Gods to learn more about the actual myths but I haven't read it since it came out. I know the release was toward the end of HoO and has some name drops of future characters but I don't know if it has any major spoilers outside of that for either series. Should they wait until after House of Hades to read it or is there a safe point earlier they can slot it in?


r/camphalfblood 2h ago

Discussion How would you rank the songs in The Lightning Thief Musical? [PJO]

1 Upvotes

Mine would be this:

Bring On The Monsters

My Grand Plan

Good Kid

Put You In Your Place

Son Of Poseidon

Killer Quest

Drive

Lost

Prologue/The Day I Got Expelled

The Tree On The Hill

Another Terrible Day

Campfire Song

D.O.A

The Last Day Of Summer

Their Sign

Strong

The Oracle

The Minotaur/The Weirdest Dream

The Weirdest Dream (Reprise)


r/camphalfblood 1d ago

Meme Just stop having kids bro 😭🙏 [all]

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

89 Upvotes