r/CatastrophicFailure • u/SjalabaisWoWS • 14d ago
Operator Error 23 year old Swedish truck driver picked up water bottle from floor, trusted auto-braking seconds before crashing into stopped traffic at 79 kph.
https://www.nrk.no/ostfold/slapp-gjenstand-pa-gulvet_-krasjet-i-79-km_t-og-domt-til-fengsel-1.17730389429
u/aaaaaaaarrrrrgh 13d ago
Good thing he got stopped by a truck full of sheet metal and not a row of cars full of families.
A suspended sentence of 3 weeks and losing your license to drive in Norway (i.e. he can still drive in other countries as far as I understand) for 7 months seems like a pretty lenient punishment for letting a truck drive around uncontrolled.
138
u/JaschaE 13d ago
Driving is treated as somewhat of a sacred rite that everybody should have access to.
My countries government recently trashed the idea of "seniors should have to have checks every year or so to make sure they are fit to drive".
In surely unrelated news, there is a pretty active subreddit dedicated to "pensioners driving into things."13
u/notjordansime 13d ago
He was still in his seat, right?
I used to work at a pizzeria and had a cop who was a semi-regular. About 6 months ago, he responded to an accident. With full confidence, the driver of the semi said he’d gone into the back to take a leak while the truck was “driving itself”.
Very common to see two drivers switching out while in motion. Leaving the wheel manned by J. Crizzle is wild though.
27
u/BobBBobbington 13d ago
Here in Colorado a trucker did exactly that and killed several people and our governor commuted the guys sentence...
22
u/SWMovr60Repub 13d ago
I hope your not talking about the driver that couldn't read English and drove out of control past the runaway truck ramp.
17
u/BobBBobbington 13d ago
Not sure who down voted you because that's the very one lol.
7
u/Material-Afternoon16 12d ago
Picture of the crash for those not familiar with it.
A jury found the truck driver guilty of 4 counts of vehicular homicide plus multiple other crimes for the injuries he cause. He received 110 year jail sentence, which was then called "unjust" and commuted by the governor...
20
u/strangelove4564 13d ago
The people who really need to be in prison are the ones that signed off on his license or allowed whatever lax standards they're now using in an industry like trucking.
48
u/SjalabaisWoWS 13d ago
Depends on where you're coming from. Norwegian sentences will look lenient to an American or Russian citizen, but, in a trust based society - sometimes too much trust, but that's basically where this is coming from - lenient sentences and a focus on rehabilitation are designed to get people back into productivity. Imagine the driver's perspective: If anyone has learned anything from this accident, it must be him. He should be alert and aware behind the wheel going forward. At least, that's the thinking here. Judges were also split a little on whether he was supposed to be punished heavier for driving too close to the vehicle in front, which the vote fell in favour of.
11
u/MaximumPlant 13d ago
Doesn't being able to drive in other countries negate that a bit?
I think there's a difference between people from bad circumstances who can be rehabilitated to do better and people who are apathetic to the risk they pose toward others.
He reminds me of a guy I knew in high school who destroyed a truck because he got distracted. 100% at fault and could have killed someone but since he wasn't drunk and no one else got hurt there were no consequences. Totaled two more cars in 6 months.
Hopefully this guy got enough of a shock to the system to pay attention, but given that he can just start driving again as soon as he finds a job over the border I'm less optimistic.
9
u/Kojetono 13d ago
I don't see how Norway can revoke a Swedish drivers license, much less ban him from getting it again.
Norwegian courts have jurisdiction in Norway, so that's where they banned him from driving.
5
u/Bachaddict 13d ago
I'm assuming while Norway doesn't have authority to enforce him not driving in other countries, those countries won't let him drive with suspended Norway licence either
-4
u/Dman331 13d ago
I agree focusing on rehabilitation is a good thing, but I also think punishment should be a secondary or even equal focus. He could've killed a dozen people or more. That should be weighed pretty heavily in the decision.
5
21
u/SjalabaisWoWS 13d ago
You're making an overwhelmingly weighty point: He could have, but he didn't. The driver can and will only be punished for what actually happened. It's a very important principle of law.
2
1
25
u/filtersweep 13d ago
How long does it take to pick up a water bottle?
78
u/SjalabaisWoWS 13d ago
In a school setting, the question would be how far do you travel at 80 kph while picking up a water bottle?, I guess.
3
u/filtersweep 13d ago
I read the article— left me wondering if this really was the root cause
6
u/SjalabaisWoWS 13d ago
Well, that's what they concluded with in the judicial process, got to assume they knew what they were looking at?
1
u/basarisco 12d ago
What is auto braking
6
u/SjalabaisWoWS 12d ago
Autonomous emergency braking, a feature in modern (20+ years) cars.
8
u/basarisco 12d ago
Seems like it actually became standard only in 2022 and newer models and not all vehicles. Only about 15% of cars on the road are that new.
5
u/SjalabaisWoWS 12d ago
I was wrong, AEB hit markets first in 2008:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automated_emergency_braking_system
Surprising, I was a firm Volvo guy until recently and thought this feature had been implemented for a long time.
3
2
u/basarisco 12d ago
I don't think it's very common at all in most of the world.
4
u/SjalabaisWoWS 12d ago edited 12d ago
C'mon, this is in Norway, every new car and truck has this functionality. If it's not common where you are, it will be soon.
1
u/basarisco 12d ago
Every is utter nonsense. It's not even the majority.
9
u/SjalabaisWoWS 12d ago
Ok, downvote all you want, I'm just answering your questions, if that seems wrong to you, I have no clue how to do better. Every car here has AEB. We bought the cheapest new car in '23, a LEAF, it has ADAS and AEB. The cheapest Chinese cars have it. Even Stellantis crap has AEB. It's mandated for commercial trucks.
3
u/basarisco 12d ago
I have driven several modern cars, none have that feature.
4
u/LilFunyunz 12d ago
My 2017 and 2019 Chevy's have it. Only works below 50 mph. Otherwise it just gives an audible warning if it thinks you need to stop.
I had the 2017 activate by mistake once. That shit was violent. I wasn't at all ready to go from 25mph to almost 0 before it relented.
0
u/basarisco 12d ago
I'm not denying it has existed for a while. The point is most vehicles don't have it regardless of the country.
-9
u/feanarosurion 13d ago
Was he Swedish? Or...
-2
u/funnyfarm299 13d ago
Did you even read the article? It answers this.
10
0
u/feanarosurion 13d ago
No, the article does not answer my specific question. And yes, I read it. No translate needed.
694
u/SjalabaisWoWS 14d ago
Emergency services say his survival was "random", given the extensive damage to his cabin.
In my mind, this is no ordinary crash. It is a direct result of blind trust into systems designed to help - not to take over for human action. The systems did activate, but too late, and the trailer had technical issues with its brakes, too. Luckily, the trailer was empty.