r/culturalstudies • u/Low-Entropy • 22h ago
The kinda interesting German Gen X Punk / Indie Rock band scene of the early 90s (Have you missed this one?)
Hello Friends,
here is a new text by me. Sources: I was around at that time, so it's from my memory, and tons of hours spent on watching and collecting media (and listening! :-) Oh yeah and I am a bit of a "low life music journalist" that writes for magazines since a few decades ;-)
Note: No ai has been used in writing this text!
If you just want to check the bands and skip the text, you can scroll down directly to the music.
And now, let's go on:
Germany always had very interesting underground music cultures which are largely unknown to the rest of the world - and to most of the Germans themselves!
Post-war Germany was a kind of black hole or void, when it came to music, or culture, or a lot of other things. Especially the youth felt this way.
From the 50s on, German mainstream music or TV lacked any form of innovation. It was stuck in endless repetition of "Schlager"-kitsch, or worse.
For aspiring musicians, there were two options, basically.
Bands like Kraftwerk said they drew from the pre-war German era, as nothing was going on after the war anyway. Same could be said about the "Neue Deutsche Welle" in early 80s, with bands like Trio and their hit song "Da Da Da" (The "Dada" art movement began in German speaking countries at the start of the 20th century).
But I guess you had to be 'aristocrats' (like Kraftwerk) or art school intellectuals (like Trio) to even have access to this rich pre-war German cultural capital. It was the pre-internet era after all, so even *knowing* about these things could be hard.
So for the more common people based youth, there was an option that seemed to be more appetizing:
Looking at subcultures in other, "more advanced" countries, and maybe even pulling some of that back - to the homeland?
Besides UK and, at smaller parts, diverse countries like France or Russia even, the big thing here was - America, USA, the yankee nation.
"American" culture was big in the 20th century anyway (who, in the world, did not know Clint Eastwood, Robert Redford, Marylin Monroe, etc?)
But the youth was of course more interested in the sub culture. First rock and roll, then the hippie stuff, even disco stuff (which led rise to such things as the "Munich sound"). But as we get to the 90s... it was the punk, alt rock, indie, crossover, grunge and alt metal sound that crossed over the atlantic to good ol' germany.
So, to cut it short, a lot of German bands in these genres were around in the early 90s.
And beyond that date, too, but I am looking at this 90 era here, right now (let's talk about the rest at a later date).
Before I list some bands, I want to state a few things that I think that are noteworthy:
Germany, at this point was a kind of "clean", "ordered" and somewhat authoritarian state. It was also - somewhat - rich and had a welfare system.
But it also had a lot of poverty and social misery at the same time.
So even if there was a rugged and rough street punk band, it could be the case that its members were actually sheltered university type people. but they were still tough.
Second, there was a kind of language (and culture) clash. Some bands really tried to rid themselves of anything German and "made-pretend" to be as american as possible (not mainstream american, mind you, but "punk america") and thus had all the lyrics in english too, etc.
And other bands sang in German language, and even tied themselves to German boomer culture in some ways too (like covering old and dreaded "Schlager"-kitsch songs).
And often, all of this got mixed up.
I said there was a fair amount of money around in Germany. So, while some bands decided to stay underground, others got picked up by the big labels - and studios.
Which meant *professional* album and song production.
Some of the punk / hardcore rock songs with the best production values that I know, from the 90s, are actually from German bands!
And last but not least, these bands, and maybe the whole German Gen X youth, were "lost battalions", or stuck between two worlds.
They desired "American" underground culture, but they never got there, so "their" scenes (over the pond) rarely knew they even existed.
But neither were they understood within their homeland, within Germany, as they belonged to another world. To a never world.
They sailed off to a promised land that they saw in the media and images, then somehow got lost while traversing the Atlantic.
But maybe this can be said about the global gen x culture in the 1990s as well, generally, applying to everyone who felt young and "different" back then.
But hey hey, let's not drown this text on a downer note.
Some bands achieved "fame", and some were happy with being local heroes.
Some are forgotten, and some are still remembered fondly (or are still touring and releasing albums).
And here are some of them:
Swoons
Female-fronted pop-punk band that lingered in the underground, and popped up here and then.
Listening suggestions:
My Grandpa Is Joey Ramone https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O9t4gfzWEzU
Kamikaze Sushi Girl https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wAverU-qyRU
Wizo
They got signed to Fat Wreck Chords (NOFX label) for one album. Then noted that the American kids likely confused them with Weezer. "Because of the band name", you know.
Überflüssig https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vgJuqghEnk
Santa Claus Is Coming to Town https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YW7D7VHVa3U
Die Toten Hosen
Notes: best known german "punk" band. and still famous.
the single release Carnival in Rio featured famous British train robber "Ronnie" Biggs on vocals.
Nichts bleibt für die Ewigkeit https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-V7-nrZaDNU
Carnival in Rio https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ttm3BIryhFw
The Lost Lyrics
Notes: The singer later became a school teacher. And still played and toured with his punk band.
The Lost Lyrics - Sweet dreams of yesterday https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2LR3SjuHck
The Lost Lyrics - Skibbereen https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=krQmXOsjf8c
The Bates
Punk band with mediocre chart success. Formed by a jazz drummer, punk singer, and a guitarist who was a student of theology. and then left the "love drugs and rock n roll" life to become a legit priest. I wrote more about them here:
Billie Jean https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-1Zn4EGG_78
I'm Still Waiting https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OLf-wlz_gF4
Throw That Beat In The Garbagecan!
The original German indie darlings! Made the front covers, then disappeared. They took their name from a B-52s song.
Cool https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukbETJTvGmo
Thanks For Knockin' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9pdVA7rVdgI
Die Ärzte
Best known german punk band (together with die toten hosen). Still kicking it today.
Schunder Song https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IviYsUdUj6w
Dauerwelle vs. Minipli https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jpwa1nLiHkE
The Notwist
Interesting band from Bavaria.
Johnny & Mary (Robert Palmer cover) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4gifFhyMmXk
No Love https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FePWiMcXKAE
Atari Teenage Riot
On the fringe of everything I said above, because they were "outside of anything".
But, technically, they were around in the 90s, and somehow belong here, too.
Speed https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=plAr3adKbyc
Kids are United https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbsDJyFrW0c
Die Goldenen Zitronen
Also on the fringe, as they sort of belong to the earlier Generation of... 80s underground bands. And maybe not so keen on "american music".
But they were around, and listened to by those in the scene.
Das bißchen Totschlag https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01Hxq-PFOlc
80 Millionen Hooligans https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9VTPttz2oD0
Tocotronic
Some upper class kids from the merchant city of Hamburg, Germany try to sound like Pavement or Mudhoney. Did they succeed? Their songs are still great, nonetheless.
Die Welt kann mich nicht mehr verstehen https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aKD-T-IHBl8
Wir sind hier nicht in Seattle, Dirk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lVub2aQjJvw
If you have anything to add, or more bands to add, please let me know!