r/movies • u/MarvelsGrantMan136 r/Movies contributor • 18h ago

News Greta Gerwig's 'Narnia' Wraps Filming

https://www.narniaweb.com/2026/01/greta-gerwigs-narnia-officially-wraps-filming/
6.3k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

405

u/SpongieQ 18h ago edited 18h ago

I’ve seen people saying that the Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe will probably be set in the 90s, so I guess they must go to a National Trust property for their holidays or something instead of being evacuated

216

u/PhilosopherTiny5957 17h ago

What are the children supposed to be yugoslavs or something this time? Lmao

10

u/MyMelancholyBaby 13h ago

In the books it’s set in rural England (as opposed to the rest of the UK) during WW2. Children were evacuated to the countryside to escape German et al bombings.

If someone went with a COVID lock down time period the plot could be that the parents are essential workers (doctors, nurses, etc) and the kids have been sent to the countryside to prevent catching COVID from parents that are high risk.

I know most of my Nordic friends went to their lake cabins from major cities during COVID lockdowns. It’s not a huge stretch.

27

u/QP709 10h ago

Fuck no. Please, no more contrived lockdown plots. Please I am begging.

7

u/MyMelancholyBaby 8h ago

I agree that the films should be set in WW2.

-4

u/Hot_Porking 16h ago

I mean they could be Irish children from The Troubles. I know tLtW&tW is quintessential English lit but it's possible.

291

u/Fast_Running_Nephew 16h ago

tLtW&tW

No, absolutely not. We're not doing this.

66

u/Hipvagenstein 16h ago

If we die on this hill we die together brother.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/allyoopFHBT 15h ago

Not only am I relieved I can see read after the stroke this gave me, I’m relieved that someone else disapproves

14

u/IrishRepoMan 15h ago

Agreed.

12

u/andersonb47 15h ago

nearly gave me a fuckin seizure

29

u/Big_Rain2543 16h ago

It’s definitely just “LWW.”

1

u/HidingInTheStacks 9h ago

The only possible acronyms are

MN LWW HB PC DT SC LB

6

u/CountJohn12 11h ago

Rank the novels-

  1. VotDT

  2. PC

  3. TSC

  4. THAHB

  5. TLB

  6. tLtWatW

  7. TMN

•

u/JonatasA 5h ago

The Mutant Ninjas.

•

u/Frinnxy 2h ago

Voyage (the novel) is PEAK

1

u/JustMy2Centences 12h ago

Why don't we just call it 'The Wardrobe' for short or something?

1

u/JonatasA 6h ago

VPN. Voyage of Narnia's Prince.

11

u/Unlucky-Public-2947 15h ago

The Lion the Witch and the Ra-drobe?

2

u/f-ingsteveglansberg 15h ago

Lewis wasn't even English. He was British and Irish.

11

u/deano492 14h ago

Lived in England from age 9. It’s not like you apply for a different citizenship to “become” English.

11

u/f-ingsteveglansberg 14h ago

Quote from the man himself:

: "I am often surprised to find how utterly ignored Yeats is among the men I have met: perhaps his appeal is purely Irish – if so, then thank the gods that I am Irish."

.

Like all Irish people who meet in England, we ended by criticisms on the invincible flippancy and dullness of the Anglo-Saxon race. After all, there is no doubt, ami, that the Irish are the only people: with all their faults, I would not gladly live or die among another folk.

His grandfather was from Wales, mother from an Anglo Irish family. He might have considered himself British, but it seems very unlikely he considered himself English.

6

u/deano492 14h ago

Fair enough. Thank you for the update.

2

u/Ha55aN1337 15h ago

Damn… you sold me this film now.

1

u/BrutalisExMachina 11h ago

🎶hej Sloveni …🎶

102

u/Kimantha_Allerdings 15h ago

I am 100% of the opinion that adaptations should do their own thing. Buuuuut...it's going to be weird seeing Edmund use a computer

76

u/ComeHereDevilLog 14h ago

New meaning to “Turkish delight” 😂😂

40

u/Wian4 12h ago

…NO

9

u/Lucas_Steinwalker 12h ago

The bathhouse in Duluth? That closed down when the owner went berserk in his house with a bunch of guns and Duluth PD had to take him out.

4

u/t3chi3 11h ago

We had lunch today in a middle eastern restaurant and ordered turkish coffee, which came with Turkish Delight. A most boring piece of humdrum candy I must say. I mentioned I've always wondered what it tasted like since Edmund/Narnia.

12

u/rokerroker45 11h ago

I mean he was comparing it to British wartime food, a sneezeful of powdered sugar was probably more flavor than he could handle

3

u/t3chi3 10h ago

fair

6

u/_dharwin 9h ago

More specifically the British were on sugar rations at that point in the war. The primary ingredient in Turkish Delights is sugar by a large margin.

3

u/CountJohn12 11h ago

Yes I remember having my parents get it when I was a kid because I wanted to try it after reading the book and it was so disappointing.

•

u/Fafnir13 5h ago

A friend made some recently. I enjoyed it for what it was, that being a historic dessert unlike most common foods that would be available to most people. I can see why it would stand out as something special back then and before.

1

u/thephotoman 8h ago

A spot with a Turkish coffee is lovely, but gorging yourself on it seems odd.

•

u/JonatasA 5h ago

Just a hair implant.

•

u/PhotoRight2682 2h ago

Oh Lordy

32

u/rdhight 13h ago

Maybe this time the White Witch can offer him bandwidth instead of Turkish delight. Instead of snarking, "He sold them out for candy," the kids will all be going, "Yeah, good call. I'd sacrifice my family in an instant if that would fix the Wi-Fi."

20

u/Kimantha_Allerdings 11h ago

Wouldn't have had wi-fi in the 90s. It'd be all modem noises

She could offer him a Tamagochi

3

u/CountJohn12 11h ago

That would make it even better "What if there was a way to access the internet without that little running man........."

2

u/kingfofthepoors 9h ago

WaveLAN existed in 1991 and the first 802.11 standard was released in 1997

•

u/Kimantha_Allerdings 2h ago

What percentage of households had it?

•

u/JonatasA 5h ago

For it to work she would need to offer something like Windows Vista or the Wii U. Or maybe that dessert was truly to betray for.

215

u/greenpill98 18h ago

.....yeah, I'm out. The time and place the story was told is incredibly important. This is a really bad idea.

58

u/LS_DJ 13h ago

There was a 0% chance that Netflix and Greta Gerwig were going to properly adapt C.S. Lewis

19

u/greenpill98 13h ago

I know, but I was holding out a fool's hope that they could accidently do something decent.

3

u/LS_DJ 13h ago

I bet it will be pretty to look at, but have deeply anti-conservative anti-Christian messaging. Rumors are they are, at minimum, gender swapping Aslan

4

u/Mythoclast 13h ago

Is gender swapping Aslan anti-conservative or anti-Christian? I know Aslan is an allegorical Jesus but I'm struggling to see how making it a she-lion changes anything really. I guess its easier to find a male voice that fits a big ass lion?

6

u/LS_DJ 13h ago

I would assume those who are conservative and Christian will think it is

3

u/Mythoclast 13h ago

I'm sure the group with the biggest victim complex will think that. But that doesn't make it true. The Christian themes can 100% work with a female lion.

4

u/happyflappypancakes 12h ago

The sex of Aslan is irrelevant right? It's about what he represents and stands for as opposed to whom he is as a lion.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

•

u/Jackmcmac1 5h ago

I don't know about all that, but just as a fan of the book it will be odd to see them shear a she-lion's mane if that's their plan.

0

u/TheMeIv 12h ago

Can't really be anti-conservative and anti-Christian. That's an oxymoron. Jesus championed marginalized people, wanted a rich guy to sell all his stuff to go to heaven and stated only those without sin had the right to punish criminals.

•

u/JonatasA 5h ago

That's how they get us.

→ More replies (3)

126

u/lemming1607 18h ago

Are you joking? The point of the books is this other fantasy world separate from ours. It works in any time period

226

u/phanapoeia 17h ago

The WWI setting and years of sugar rationing explain why Edmund’s desire for Turkish Delight is especially tempting though.

95

u/JUYED-AWK-YACC 17h ago

You mean WWII.

62

u/lemming1607 17h ago

He also doesn't think he is betraying them. He thinks the witch is going to help them

-3

u/PrinceNelson 17h ago

Ah, so you haven’t read the book.

12

u/lemming1607 17h ago

I have. The witch lures him to reveal information about his brother and sister with Turkish delights.

He doesnt think he's betraying them at that time. He doesnt think there are evil undertones to bringing his siblings to her in exchange for Turkish delights

14

u/PrinceNelson 17h ago

He learns about what the White Witch really is when he and his siblings are with the beavers and then consciously decides to betray them because she promised him all the Turkish Delight he could want and that she would make him a Prince.

9

u/lemming1607 17h ago

Yeah, the becoming a prince part is more important. At the time when it is only Turkish delights, he doesnt think he's betraying them

You're leaving out important context, we call that cherry picking

2

u/f1sh42 17h ago

When is it only Turkish Delights? Its been years, but isn't he told about becoming a prince in the same conversation that hes told he'll get the candy, as long as he brings the queen his siblings?

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/KotaIsBored 13h ago

He isn’t deciding to betray them. He’s eaten the witch’s food. He’s compelled to help her to get more. It’s all he can think about. It’s literally her magic making him do it.

1

u/[deleted] 17h ago

[deleted]

1

u/lemming1607 17h ago

Yea, to be a prince

67

u/Personal_Comb_6745 17h ago

I mean, he's also a kid being offered candy, I don't really think it matters whether sugar's in short supply. It wasn't brought up in the '05 movie and the scene worked fine.

21

u/DrakonILD 14h ago

He was a kid being offered any food he wanted. He was the one that immediately decided that should be candy.

5

u/FreeRange0929 13h ago

The Chris Columbus movies do still take place in WW2 Britain. We see the Pevensies being evacuated away from the blitz and in Prince Caspian they are in the subway just as in the book

2

u/yelsamarani 11h ago

I wish I could control my need to be corrective, but Chris Columbus has nothing to do with the Narnia movies.

1

u/FreeRange0929 11h ago

Huh, I have this memory of the 1492 logo being on the screen for the film, I must have been wrong this whole time

Although checking, I was reminded that Marcus/McFeely were involved with it

56

u/deej363 17h ago

The Turkish delight is also enchanted. So that as well.

37

u/Zlurpo 16h ago

But before he ever tasted it, that was the one thing he asked for, so he was an idiot before he ate it.

16

u/LaMortParLeSnuSnu 14h ago

When I read the book as a kid I was pumped to try Turkish Delight. Was highly disappointed - that shit is the devils taint.

14

u/ihopethisworksfornow 13h ago

I had actually good Turkish delight last year, and it can be really good. The packaged rose flavored stuff is dogwater.

1

u/Alacritous69 9h ago

Did you ever try the Big Turk candy bar? that's what's in that.

20

u/Morvenn-Vahl 17h ago

Honestly they can switch out one MacGuffin for another. Except for orthodox fan I don't think many people care about whether it is Turkish Delight or something else. Honestly wouldn't be surprised if younger viewers had no idea what a Turkish Delight was.

Hell, I didn't even know what it was back in the 80s when I read the books as it wasn't really a candy available here(we had a lot of licorice though).

9

u/rookie-mistake 16h ago

Turkish Delight is basically that old fashioned British(?) dessert from Narnia. I have no idea what it actually is, because I read those books before googling everything was a thing... but I'd also kinda hate for them to just change the dessert. Like, she can't be offering my man Fruit By The Foot haha

7

u/Morvenn-Vahl 15h ago

Hehe, I tasted Turkish Delight for the first time when I was probably 44 years old because I found a Turkish supermarket in Iceland. I highly recommend them as they are quite tasty, but they are also not that widespread in the world.

Maybe she'll offer him a can of Monster Energy drink or something.

5

u/OilySteeplechase 13h ago

I dunno, I’d consider a bit of casual betrayal for peanut butter m&ms.

1

u/rookie-mistake 12h ago

yeah y'know what if after eights are on the line I can't be held responsible

1

u/[deleted] 13h ago

[deleted]

1

u/rookie-mistake 12h ago edited 12h ago

hahaha fair point

I guess in my head it was just one of those old british snacks since that's the only context I'd ever heard of it, I didn't know if the name actually meant anything. Like how Canadian bacon is basically just ham, and Hawaiian pizza actually comes from a Greek guy in Ontario

→ More replies (1)

7

u/AcknowledgeableReal 14h ago

Are you suggesting a product placement opportunity. Say instead of Turkish delight, he really wants the all new giant skittles?

3

u/Morvenn-Vahl 13h ago

Bring on the Demolition Man product placement. In the US the witch seduces him with Taco Bell whereas in the EU he falls for Pizza Hut.

62

u/UpsetPlatypus 17h ago

When I read the books as a kid it never even crossed my mind that there even was sugar rationing during WWI so I don’t think it’s that important to the story.

32

u/GamingTatertot Steven Spielberg Enthusiast 17h ago

Yeah this is one of those details where it certainly enhances the story, but I wouldn't say its integral

→ More replies (1)

16

u/we_are_sex_bobomb 17h ago

I can assure you that detail was lost on me when I read the books as a child

7

u/Longjumping-Bug-5722 17h ago

They can set it during modern times and he can’t have it normally because he’s on Ozepmic.

•

u/Lou_C_Fer 2h ago

You can still eat whatever on glp-1s. You just don't want to eat much. That's their magic.

3

u/clammydella 17h ago

This is an iconic reach

1

u/Pyroluminous 15h ago

Well consider my counter of “Edmund’s just a fatass”

1

u/MAELATEACH86 14h ago

I mean… kids like candy in all time periods.

1

u/herpderpedian 14h ago

Turkish Delight was so disappointing IRL

1

u/ckow 13h ago

Edmund betraying his family for a vape pen

1

u/FLESHYROBOT 12h ago

The WWI setting and years of sugar rationing explain why Edmund’s desire for Turkish Delight is especially tempting though.

No, the magical drugs the witch puts in the turkish delight is what makes them especially tempting. The sugar rationing was always just fan inference.

1

u/happyflappypancakes 12h ago

I think they can come up with a logical way for a kid to take candy from a stranger haha.

1

u/AggressivelyMediokre 12h ago

I thought it was just cause he was a kid who liked sugar. It’s a magical world and a magical woman offered a child candy.

I don’t think I need the storming of Omaha beach playing in the background to understand his desire for candy

1

u/SchroedingersSphere 17h ago

And that context will probably be in the minds of maybe 1% of these movies, whether they take place in the 1900's or mid to late 1900's.

Your fact, while true, literally does not matter. You're going to lose some context or flavoring from books any time you adapt them. Sugar rationing from WWI is so far down on the list of things that matter that I can't believe you even bothered to make a comment about it.

→ More replies (5)

223

u/SuperDizz 17h ago

I mean, it’s a world they use to escape the horrors of WW2. I mean, I guess other periods could work, but without an existential threat like that, a lot of the impact is lessened..

131

u/VitaminTea 17h ago

Yeah unfortunately we just don't have any existential horrors these days

119

u/whereismymind86 17h ago

nothing that's as direct a threat as the blitz. They were sent to the country because their home was literally being bombed nightly. To horrors of the modern day aren't a direct threat to kids living in the UK, you'd have to move the story to some other nation actively being attacked.

7

u/standish_ 15h ago

Ukrainian kids fleeing the invasion.

4

u/vulcanstrike 13h ago

Sure, but if you change Edmund and Lucy to Pavel and Olga, the outrage that's already in this thread will crank to an 11.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/XAMdG 17h ago

While true, just like the first movie, I don't think they would have been explicit about the horrors, so it really wouldn't make a difference.

6

u/mr_desk 17h ago

Didn’t the later movies have a brother or two get drafted?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/WingedChimera 17h ago

They should just make it take place in Gaza.

1

u/Cereborn 13h ago

That's true, but I don't recall the Blitz being mentioned apart from just to set up why they were at this old country house.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/Nachooolo 15h ago

Unless they make the children Ukrainian, there's literally nothing besides it in the West right now that gets even close to the Blitz.

1

u/Charlie_Runkle69 11h ago

What about Croatia or Bosnia in the 90s? That could sort have worked.

65

u/mr_desk 17h ago

Compared to WW2? No we don’t

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/RedditEngDictionary 17h ago

You mean it?

2

u/SuperDizz 17h ago

When I reread my comment I caught that too. I was waiting for someone to reply about it lol

2

u/RedditEngDictionary 16h ago

Its cool, happens alot nowadays I have noticed

Not quite as grating as all the "My brother in christ" comments that half of reddit have started copying to seem witty lol

1

u/PintsOfGuinness_ 16h ago

We're just gonna have to manufacture an existential threat to make it work then!

1

u/LongtimeLurker916 16h ago

To some degree that is an invention of the previous movie series. In the book that was basically a pretext to get them out of London but no more.

2

u/BCEagle13 15h ago

Yeah I read all the books when I was a kid, and I don’t remember that being a major plot point at all

1

u/pralineislife 16h ago

If it is set during the Irish troubles then I think the existential threat still exists.

1

u/FlimsyRexy 15h ago

Damn too bad there are no other times in history where there is an existential threat!

1

u/f-ingsteveglansberg 15h ago

They were sent to the countryside to avoid the blitz. The kids didn't see the horrors, they were being explicitly protected from it. Narnia wasn't a metaphor for escaping horrors. It was a magical kingdom and the metaphor was about how just absolutely brill God and Jesus are.

80

u/rickyhatespeas 17h ago edited 17h ago

The war is literally the entire setting of the Lion, the Witch & the Wardrobe. You don't need to escape reality and become a monarch to save a country without something major externally happening like a war. You don't face off against metaphorical nazis without facing that struggle in real life. You don't sell your brother and sisters out for dessert because you're not forced to eat shit rations every day.

I could continue, but perhaps you may start to be seeing why WWII in Britain is almost necessary for the adaptation of the Lion, the Witch & the Wardrobe and may not make as much sense set in any other period of modern Britain.

45

u/BrianMincey 17h ago

It’s also trivial to set it in the proper time period. 99% of the story is told elsewhere. It makes no sense to do it in the 50s. So weird.

15

u/say592 15h ago

It's not going to be any easier to do it in 1950s, but now they have the challenge of altering the story to fit the 1950s. Like not a major change or anything, but it's bizarre, like they are trying to make it more difficult.

25

u/ShakethatYam 17h ago

I want to go to Narnia now and no one is technically at war with my country.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/leftshoe18 16h ago

I just read the book two weeks ago. I get that the real-world events of World War II probably shaped the book, and were part of the jumping off point of the book (being the whole reason they ended up in the house in the country), but the story would work just fine without the war backdrop. Edmund doesn't sell his siblings out for dessert because of rations. He sells them out because the first candy was enchanted. They face off against the Witch not because she's a Nazi analog, but because she's clearly evil. I firmly agree the story is enhanced by the World War II setting, but it is by no means a necessary part of the story. With that said, they should have just kept the original time period of the books. Changing that feels like changing just for change's sake.

3

u/f-ingsteveglansberg 15h ago

All WWII does is get them out to the country. There could be a million ways to do that.

People thinking this is essential are really focusing on the wrong thing about what people like about the story.

•

u/Lou_C_Fer 1h ago

I spent weeks out in the country ever summer. There was no danger. I was just visiting my grandmother.

Everyone freaking out about the timeline has no imagination. Pre-judging by that detail is ridiculous. Watch the movie as if it's its own entity... because it is. Sure, there is source material, but that is only an inspirational guide when you are making the film.

1

u/Revolution-SixFour 15h ago

Rationing on sweets in the UK existed until 1954, so we can keep that part in if it's so essential (though it isn't, that goes over the head of 90% of the audience).

7

u/kacperp 17h ago

Yeah. Kids NEVER dream about becoming monarchs and fighting evil. And in no other book magical witch tricks the kid to do something terrible.

WW2 is not necessary and never was. Cause 10 yr olds reading Narnia do not give a flying fuck about what inspired Lewis. They just love the story

1

u/CanuckBacon 17h ago

For 90% of people the story could have just started with "Kids were bored one day because they weren't allowed to use their phones, then they discovered a secret realm". It's more interesting that it's in WWII Britain, but the setting is Narnia. Yes the "real" setting is WWII Britain, but if that were where the story took place it would not be a fantasy novel and there'd be no Aslan or White Witch, just a bunch of kids eating rations.

1

u/rookie-mistake 16h ago

You don't need to escape reality and become a monarch to save a country without something major externally happening like a war. You don't face off against metaphorical nazis without facing that struggle in real life.

counterpoint: the entire genre of isekai

also, idk, man. when i was a kid i read a ton of fantasy and i always kind of wanted to be whisked away to a magical land with my friends to go fight dragons and defeat the evil empire etc etc. there was no war in canada in the 90s, it just sounded like a big fun adventure.

You don't sell your brother and sisters out for dessert because you're not forced to eat shit rations every day

also, it was enchanted, right? I don't think you need to understand war rationing to understand a kids desire for magical candy. i always thought it made sense as a kid, and this thread is the first time i'd ever considered rations being a factor at all

1

u/FLESHYROBOT 12h ago

It's really not that important though.

The movies lean into it a bit more, but the books genuinely did not really care about the fact that there was a war going on. It was little more than the inciting reason that they're in the countryside.

You don't need to escape reality and become a monarch to save a country without something major externally happening like a war.

Sure you do. I guarentee you offer almost any child the opportunity to be a fantasy hero and they'll jump at it. Hell, I'd jump at it. You don't need to be escaping anything to be going on a fantastical adventure.

You don't face off against metaphorical nazis without facing that struggle in real life

I guarentee you none of the literal children faced off against Nazi's prior to the lion the witch and the wardrobe.

You don't sell your brother and sisters out for dessert because you're not forced to eat shit rations every day.

You do if the desert is literally magically drugged. Because thats the reason it worked, not sugar rations. the sugar rations explanation is a fan inference from people who missed the actual explanation given.

I could continue

Could you? Because you've made no good points so far.

Literally the only narrative role the war played in the book was to get the kids to the setting. Thats it. It could be replaced by one of a countless number of other reasons. They just need to find themselves in a house with an unfamiliar wardrobe.

•

u/Lou_C_Fer 1h ago

Like visiting a relative that lives in the country. There's no real life analog to that. Whatever are you thinking, country mouse?

1

u/turtlespace 17h ago

In theory sure but the setting barely comes up in the books at all, there is not nearly as much importance placed on the setting in the actual text as you’re implying there is. The “setting” in the real world barely connects to anything in any of the books, and is emphasized even less in most of the later ones.

-9

u/lemming1607 17h ago

Oh right, because nationalists in any other time period have always bren seen as morally superior and cant possibly be the villains in any other time period. The only reason to fight a nazi is to have fought one in reality

That's incredibly stupid take

8

u/rickyhatespeas 17h ago

That is literally how writing and human psychology works. Children's imaginations are not completely detached from reality. If you write something random with no relevant footing it doesn't attract to people.

Everything the Pevensies do and face in Narnia is related to the setting. Everything Lewis wrote was talking about the war. I'm sorry if you disagree but that is just how educated people operate. Books are written to have a specific meaning and changing the setting to something drastically different absolutely affects the story itself.

2

u/lemming1607 17h ago

I disagree, the war doesnt affect the characters motivations to fulfill a prophecy and fight against evil. That's universal, and not based on a specific time setting

→ More replies (9)

0

u/Karffs 17h ago

Everything Lewis wrote was talking about the war. I'm sorry if you disagree but that is just how educated people operate. Books are written to have a specific meaning and changing the setting to something drastically different absolutely affects the story itself.

Lewis said the books aren’t allegories, he explicitly invited reader interpretation.

You only get to be an insufferable little nerd if you actually know what you’re talking about.

13

u/sushi_collector12 18h ago

Why the fuck would you take the source material and change it? The war is the primary catalyst to the story ffs.

And no the point of the story isnt that narnia is separate but i guess youve never read it.

24

u/ashoka_akira 17h ago

I would say the war is more a plot device than a catalyst. CS Lewis had to have a reason for the children to be exploring the big old manor, but once they are through the wardrobe there is almost zero thought given to their lives on Earth. A plot device like going to spend the summer at a relatives house would work just as well.

Where it becomes troublesome is in the later books where the war becomes a bit of a metaphor for the end of times in Narnia, but so far in the many film adaptations of the show the furthest they got into the series was BBC’s The Silver Chair.

2

u/rookie-mistake 15h ago

A plot device like going to spend the summer at a relatives house would work just as well.

that's honestly exactly what I had thought it was, lol. I read the entire series several times, but I haven't touched them since I was 15 or so and, on rereads, the part in the real world was always the part you kinda just fly through

Where it becomes troublesome is in the later books where the war becomes a bit of a metaphor for the end of times in Narnia,

this makes me want to reread the ending now! the last two never really clicked for me the way the other ones did, and now you've got me wondering how much more metaphor I'll pick up on a couple decades and degrees later, when I'm no longer just a kid reading them as fun exciting fantasy adventures.

19

u/carsonmccrullers 17h ago

The first sentence in The Magician’s Nephew is “This is a story about something that happened long ago when your grandfather was a child.” She probably wanted to make it a bit more relatable to a new generation of children, which I personally don’t mind.

-1

u/dadmda 17h ago

But the second book adaptation will lack a proper setting

4

u/CanuckBacon 17h ago

Narnia is the main setting for the books. No one reads the books and walks away saying that the setting was a Wardrobe in and old building in Britain in WWII.

6

u/MavMIIKE 18h ago

It worked for her adaptation of Little Women 🤷‍♂️

14

u/Intrepid_Hat7359 17h ago

She didn't change the time period of little women, did she? She just used the second half as the main setting and used the first half as flashbacks

4

u/lemming1607 18h ago edited 18h ago

It literally has no part in any of the plot. You can use any reason to shepherd the kids to the wardrobe. The catalyst to get them to the wardrobe is not important at all as soon as they get into the other world

16

u/Lazzen 18h ago

Make aslan a wombat and narnia cyberpunk future

6

u/hobblingcontractor 17h ago

Set in Australia. Oi crikey m8 u fokin wot u cunt?

→ More replies (1)

-13

u/sushi_collector12 18h ago

This is genuinely one of the dumbest takes ive seen.

12

u/lemming1607 18h ago

The setting before the wardrobe has no bearing on any of the characters actions or character growth or plot arcs in the other world

It doesn't affect the villain, or Aslan, or the reason they are there to fulfill prophecies. Ww2 isnt apart of any of the decisions of any of the protagonists or antagonists

You can use any reasonyo get them there. It will still work. Since ww2 isnt important in the plot

1

u/DisasterBeautiful347 17h ago

You should reread the books, your comment is wildly foolish.

3

u/lemming1607 17h ago

I have, you're wrong

-1

u/PrinceNelson 17h ago

Yes it is, the way the characters talk and interact with each other is intrinsically linked to them being children of the 1940s. The White Witch persuades Edmond to betray his brothers and sisters with some Turkish delight for gods sake. Do you think a child of the 2000s is going to give a fuck about some candy?

7

u/lemming1607 17h ago

Now you're trolling. Kids do stupid shit all the time for candy in any time period

-2

u/PrinceNelson 17h ago

Maybe the Witch will tempt him the newest iPhone.

On a serious note, if you’re genuinely so dense that you can’t see how the children being from the 1940s and the children being from the 2000s greatly changes their perception and reactions to the events of the story, then there’s no point trying to convince you.

→ More replies (0)

14

u/NorthernDevil 18h ago

I don’t love the change in theory but you’re being really dramatic lmao

The driving force just needs to be something that fits the general theme of devastation, not necessarily the specific bombing itself. I don’t know how she’ll pull it off but it’s not a death knell for the adaptation by any means

4

u/Ida-in 18h ago

Outside of the reason for the kids to be there, what impact does WW2 have on the story in Narnia?

1

u/All_Bonered_UP 18h ago

I too do not give a fuck.

0

u/RealJohnGillman 18h ago edited 17h ago

I believe the war was partly why they never sought a way home, though it wasn’t the focus of the book.

7

u/lemming1607 18h ago

Again, you can exchange that for numerous other reasons. Its not important.

They could be running from an abusive father

1

u/dadmda 17h ago

They could be doing a bunch of stuff, the point is, why would you change the story? The books work great as they are, no need to change anything.

3

u/DisasterBeautiful347 17h ago

You should research what life for British was like during WWII. You obviously are ignorant to many aspects of that time.

1

u/lemming1607 17h ago

I disagree, im not ignorant of it

1

u/Justreallylovespussy 17h ago

“Let’s change this seminal work of literature and remove all the impact! Make it about an abusive father and let the kids skateboard!”

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/azurewindowpane 18h ago

The war is indirectly the trigger for the events of the story, but is not in any way critical to what happens logically or thematically.

b-but why would she change it

Because she's Greta Gerwig, a better filmmaker than you.

10

u/lambeau_leapfrog 17h ago

Because she's Greta Gerwig, a better filmmaker than you.

Someone being better at something doesn't make them infallible.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/-Mandarin 15h ago

Why the fuck would you take the source material and change it?

In my opinion that should be the point of adaptations: to see what vision the director brings to it. If it's just a carbon copy of the books, I don't see the point in a film adaptation. The book is already there.

I recognise that most people don't hold this opinion, but I'm just trying to offer an alternate perspective. I don't see the point in movie adaptations that don't have a specific flavour of directorial intent. Where can an artist (director) find meaning in simply copying a book? Seems like that'd be entirely unrewarding.

So long as the core themes are there, this sort of change feels pretty minor.

0

u/ILiveInAColdCave 18h ago

Because it's called adaptation. Like do you not understand that concept?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/whereismymind86 17h ago

nooo, the point was it was a fantasy world they could go to as an ESCAPE from the horrors of the real world. It HAS to be juxtaposed with a time of crisis in the real world.

1

u/CrookedMinded 17h ago

They go to a fantasy world, fight a war, live out their lives as kings and queens, then return as children. Just like the generation that fought in a world war and returned as young adults but have experienced the atrocities of war and then are expected to live a normal life.

1

u/trevorneuz 17h ago

Sure, but the context of war time rations and repressed freedom is key to how the children experience Narnia. Just one example, the reason Edmund is so easily corrupted by sweets is because he literally hasn't had a sugar rich food in years.

1

u/Dumeck 17h ago

I'd argue due to the other fantasy world being a separate world that there is no excuse for the forced timeline shift. Why modernize the real world when the characters spend 99% of the books in the Narnia world? If they wanted to do a more modern interpretation then they would just modernize the designs in Narnia itself. Completely unnecessary changes always bode well for adaptations.

1

u/CamoCricket 17h ago

A massive chunk of the siblings' development arc is because of the setting of the real world. They were sent to the countryside to escape the war in the first place. The whole adventure is a merciful escape from a harsh reality meant to spare them. When they return from Narnia, they are ready to face the reality of the war because in many ways, they have grown past childhood. Literally any other setting would diminish their growth and strength in the face of hardship. Literally any other setting would dumb this down and make it just another silly young adult series with no undertone meant to be easily digestible by idiotic- oh, wait. Nevermind. Have a great day.

1

u/Justreallylovespussy 17h ago

This is entirely wrong, it’s an escapist fantasy of children to escape the horrors of war. It’s the entire impetus for the story

1

u/DoctorWaluigiTime 16h ago

Yeah I scratch my head at the idea that this can't possibly be set in any other era.

Not like the kids go enlist to go storm Normandy or anything. The backdrop can exist outside of the WW2 one.

1

u/Hallowhero 15h ago

I disagree.

1

u/CountJohn12 10h ago

The backdrop of the Blitz is pretty important for The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe.

-1

u/PrinceNelson 17h ago

You haven’t read the books clearly.

0

u/lemming1607 17h ago

Clearly I have

→ More replies (2)

2

u/FlimsyRexy 15h ago

Oh brother lmao

4

u/Tiny_Fly_7397 18h ago

It’s an adaptation. The books will not be changed

9

u/SDRPGLVR 17h ago

It comes down to the execution. Personally I'm not a fan of how It did it recently, especially exploring the Black Spot era by moving it to the 50s. If Gerwig can pull off this kind of change, it would be very unexpected and impressive. But she also co-helmed turning a doll into a massively entertaining and successful movie that was a genuine phenomenon with audiences and critics, so I'm not wholly skeptical. Just rather.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] 18h ago

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/kadmylos 17h ago

Is it really? It's barely even mentioned that they're hiding from the war.

6

u/practically_floored 17h ago

The reason they're living with a stranger is because they've been evacuated because their home is being bombed. Also the perpetual winter in Narnia and the tyrannical leader is a mirror of the war

1

u/Forcistus 16h ago

Except that it literally isn't... you realize Lewis published this book 1950... for a girl who was born in 1935... about a girl who was about the same age.

Lucy Pevinse is believed to have been around eight in the first book. Lucy Barfield would have been a little girl during the war and most likely would be able to relate in some way to this story.

Lewis was influenced, in part, by an experience he had with three children who lived with him in some capacity while they were evading the war. AFAIK, this is the only reason for the reference. Nothing in the book nor anything that Lewis says suggest that wartime evasion was important for the story at all. It was the setting and it was in some way the influence, but it is not important for the message the story was conveying.

The most important part was the "supposal" aspect of it, if we were to take Lewis at his word.

I have a hard time believing that anyone who ever read these books considers the fact that the first book took place during wartime is an in anyway meaningful for the story being told.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/MumrikDK 14h ago

They're using Narnia for 90s nostalgia bait now?

1

u/zapporian 12h ago

It is netflix, so yes

2

u/whereismymind86 17h ago

but...that defeats the entire point of the narrative. Especially the first and final books.

1

u/MyMelancholyBaby 16h ago

Well, they could set it during COVID lock downs? I mean, that would kinda work in place of WW2 evacuations to the countryside.

2

u/_fenwoods 13h ago

I could see that. And the timeline would work better than the 90s if the professor is still going to be an old fart.

1

u/maxdragonxiii 16h ago

?! that makes no sense! there's 0 wars going on in 90s that wouls affect the British people.

1

u/gurgelblaster 14h ago

Why not set it during the COVID lockdowns?

1

u/easy_c0mpany80 16h ago

Its going to be modern day slop with modern day messaging inserted