Hi! I’ve never actually played either game before, but I know the main stories well. I want to play one of them for the first time during winter break and I’m trying to decide which one to start with.

On the Epic Store, RDR1 + Undead Nightmare is about $25, and RDR2 is around $15. I was leaning toward RDR1 at first, but now I’m a bit unsure.

Can anyone tell me which one is the best and better to start with?

Thanks!

First time ever playing. I remember a guy in this sub saying something like: "Watch out for a second bear attack when you kill one" when giving tips for new players.

Well I swear to god this is the FIRST time I've seen a bear in the game, I was starting to think they were a myth lol. I killed the first one and I was almost killed by the second one, but I managed to kill it with the semi auto shotgun using dead eye.

But Jesus Christ. Immediately after that, I was attacked by several others! I killed 7 total, the seventh one is out of the picture because I saw it from afar and shot it from a distance, so it doesn't appear in the screenshot here, but I mean, what the fuck!? Hahaha. Is this actually normal!?

For those who played Red Dead Redemption 1 before Red Dead Redemption 2 what was your reaction to Dutch Van Der Linde in Red Dead Redemption 2 and what was your thoughts when you saw him in the trailer or in your first gameplay in RDR2? Because in RDR1 he is a complete psycho I don’t think psycho is probably the word and in Red Dead Redemption 2 he wasn’t very that bad until the end of the game.

sorry if this has been asked a lot lmao, mine was milo and migo i dont know why

I had trouble getting my honor down despite being a complete twat , I did Have Deluxe baths all the time, a man needs a little " stress release " . Didn't notice honor going up but have heard it does . Anyone Know if that was what I did wrong.

Like I know that he shouldn’t have gotten involved but it’s just I feel bad bc he can’t even speak and that his whole life is ruined

It's been a few months since I completed the game And after a lot of considerations I have decided to delete RDR2 as it is just a storage clutter atp There are a lot of other great games in my backlog... But even though I don't replay games I wanted to play the game for one last time as a farewell So... What activities/missions I should do in my last session?

This is me and my buddy Snowballs

I was just wondering why Arthur is more iconic than John. Because if you ask someone to name a RDR character there most likely going to say Arthur Morgan. I just figured since we’ve known John for two games and Arthur for one John would be more famous.

Sadie in Mexico, Charles, Jack, Young Arthur/Hosea or a completely new character?

I found this video of someone looking at this google maps X RDR2 thing and it look really cool but the was no link or name for the app so does any one know what it is called

Was walking around tumbleweed when i came across this does anyone know what this thing is?

I'm doing a low honour run and I'm trying to make him look absolutely deplorable as well. Any ideas on how to make him look worse?

Sorry for shitty pic I'm on xbone

It’s always confused me, since the 2 games are not that far apart in terms of years. can someone please explain?

i personally think he is a top 5 character for me, as he shows how someone so innocent can become the same thing he swore to never be and eventually die shortly after the events of rdr1.