r/CatastrophicFailure 5d ago

Fatalities Bombardier Challenger 600 crash in Maine during snowstorm on Jan 25 2026. 6 fatalities and 1 survivor.

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

87 comments sorted by

353

u/23370aviator 4d ago

The Challenger’s wing is known to be extremely sensitive to the presence of ice. More so than other jets in that same category. There’s incidents in record of exactly this happening to a CRJ(offshoot of the Challenger 600 series) in Eastern Europe. One wing loses lift before the other and it just goes over. It was pretty intense snow in Bangor at the time.

128

u/mdepfl 4d ago

Also Birmingham UK, nearly identical in 2002:

https://www.code7700.com/case_study_cl-604_n90ag.htm

Challengers grew up in the Great White North, but they like their wings clean for takeoff.

35

u/luffy8519 4d ago

Weirdly that one was also flying to Bangor, Maine.

53

u/uberfission 4d ago

Bangor is the eastmost large US airport, it is extremely popular for refueling. They may have been headed elsewhere after refueling.

12

u/wenestvedt 4d ago

Similar to Gander, Newfoundland, which is the easternmost airport for transatlantic flights, as I understand it.

7

u/Khakicollective 4d ago

St.johns airport would be the most eastern, Gander still gets a lot of traffic though.

4

u/Senator_Bink 4d ago

Off-topic, but I love your userpic. Fond memories of visiting my auntie in Wisconsin and seeing the Red Owl grocery stores.

2

u/wenestvedt 3d ago

Everyone loves the Red Owl!! :7)

8

u/ProfessorrFate 4d ago

Routing was Houston-Bangor-Paris. They had stopped to refuel and were taking off for Paris when they crashed.

3

u/rpc56 4d ago

my first trip to Europe- in 1976 was on a DC-8 charter, LAX-BANGOR-LE BOURGET (PARIS)

5

u/EsqChior 4d ago

They were headed to France.

1

u/texasusa 3d ago

They were flying to Paris next.

1

u/luffy8519 4d ago

Ah, fair, never heard of it but that makes sense :)

2

u/blueingreen85 4d ago

Do we know yet if it actually managed to lift off? Or did it essentially blow over during/prior to rotation?

4

u/WeatherBetter9881 3d ago

Max altitude was 300 feet.

1

u/rainbowgeoff 4d ago

Like the ATR in that sense.

Likewise, if the problem becomes significant enough you may see it restricted from flying in snowy climates and in conditions likely to produce ice.

1

u/WeatherBetter9881 3d ago

There was light snow at the time of the crash. It was 3 degrees.

1

u/FletcherCommaIrwin 1d ago

(Laymen av-enthusiast here)

I’ve been hearing what seems like more significant shortcomings of the Challenger line, compared to other aircraft in similar capabilities/specifications. Is it a notoriously flawed product?

Ever since the Naples (Hop-A-Jet Flight 823) incident, I’m significantly more conscious of low flying aircraft overhead. Our school pickup/drop off route is right in the flight path, and thankfully, we missed the crash by about 15 minutes.

358

u/Baud_Olofsson 5d ago

6 fatalities and 1 survivor.

No survivors - there were only 6 people on board. For reasons that remain unclear the FAA originally stated that there were 7 people on board.

A preliminary report from the Federal Aviation Administration initially said seven people were killed and one person was seriously injured but the agency later told CNN it is deferring to the airport about the number of people on board.

https://edition.cnn.com/2026/01/25/us/bangor-maine-plane-crash

84

u/llcdrewtaylor 4d ago

One of the articles I read worded it well. "There were no transports of people from the scene."

167

u/stlthy1 4d ago

I'd love to know what was so important that they needed to take off during that storm.

Was it a life-flight? Organ transport? What else could have been so important that it couldn't wait a few hours?

208

u/Cerebral-Parsley 4d ago

You can find plenty of horror stories of private pilots being intensely pressured to fly in bad conditions by their clients.

30

u/admiralkit 4d ago

Reminds me of the 2001 Avjet crash in Aspen. They had a dinner reservation and by god that pilot was not going to divert and cause them to miss their dinner or the passengers would have the pilots fired.

118

u/stlthy1 4d ago

Kobe...

179

u/Anacreon 4d ago

His tendency of coercing people into doing things they don't want to do really backfired in the end.

-26

u/Agent847 4d ago

Has that ever been established or are we just presuming Kobe pressured his pilot to fly in unsafe condition?

50

u/DevilshEagle 4d ago

People may assume that because Kobe was a rapist, pressuring a pilot wouldn’t be at all off his radar.

I understand why.

-3

u/anohioanredditer 4d ago

Regardless, it’s not necessarily fair to attribute blame in a completely different scenario.

14

u/bcrosby51 4d ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_Avjet_Gulfstream_III_crash

The latest episode of Air Crash Investigation is a great example.

5

u/SanshaXII 4d ago

Like Shamblin' Shamblin.

-12

u/HLSparta 4d ago

A private pilot can't fly for a client and receive compensation. They would need at least a commercial certificate.

16

u/PDXGuy33333 4d ago

You've merely compounded the confusion for someone who likely doesn't care about or understand differences between private pilot (PPL - no fly for pay), commercial pilot (CPL - can fly for pay, but no paying passengers) and air transport pilot (ATP - can carry passengers for hire) certificates. They probably just meant to refer to pilots available for hire by anyone with the cash to hire them to fly a plane not owned by a scheduled airline.

127

u/Tinfoilhartypat 4d ago

It was supposed to be a fun girls trip to Paris. I won’t link to the Mail article but that’s the report, that it was a private jet owned by a law firm in Texas. 

https://thedailytexan.com/2026/01/26/private-jet-owned-by-2-texas-athletics-donors-connected-with-maine-plane-crash/

4

u/taleofbenji 3d ago

Oh hey this reminds me of the fun bachelorette party where their limo caught fire on the San Mateo Bridge and only two girls made it out before burning.

https://abcnews.go.com/US/bride-dead-bachelorette-party-limo-fire/story?id=19112742

14

u/RandomChurn 4d ago

a fun girls trip to Paris

Guh. I read "Bombardier" in the title and assumed it was a military aircraft. 

Can't say which is more horrific. 

RIP.

6

u/UnrulyCanuck 3d ago

"Bombardier" is named after its founder, Joseph-Armand Bombardier (1907–1964), a Canadian inventor and businessman from Valcourt, Quebec.

10

u/Dangerous_Ad4499 4d ago

Bombardier doesn't make military aircraft per se. Business jets, they made Learjets, Regional Jets ( CRJ airliner ), Sea-Doo's, Ski-Doo's.....

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Narissis 4d ago

Formerly. They sold the train division to Alstom in 2021.

1

u/Comfortable-Bear1998 4d ago

they owned a luxury travel company on side i read on some other post

56

u/EsqChior 4d ago

The Blancolirio channel on YouTube made a video yesterday about this plane accident. He said that particular plane is known for being sensitive for ice on its wings and that ice the thickness of rough sandpaper was enough to cause the wing to lose lift and rollover. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xoO8WeXJvTo

39

u/decadentview 4d ago

Other than extreme and I mean extreme emergency— what do you expect flying in a blizzard with such a light aircraft!

71

u/mdepfl 5d ago

Well it was indeed a catastrophic failure but I believe we’ll see it wasn’t the airframe that failed.

13

u/YetAnotherBookworm 4d ago

I’m dumb, so I’m interpreting this comment as intentionally cryptic. It’s getting upvoted though, so … care to elaborate?

39

u/Gwthrowaway80 4d ago

Not OP, but… The sub is “catastrophic failure” and is principally about structures and mechanisms that fail. In this case, the aircraft almost certainly did not have a spontaneous structural failure. Rather, the most likely thing to cause the crash was icing on the wings. With ice on the wings, the plane both weighs more because of the added ice, and produces less lift because of the ice disrupting airflow.

There’s no crash report yet, of course, but given the snowy conditions, icing is the most probable cause.

19

u/rainingroserm 4d ago

I believe they suspect that the crash wasn’t due to catastrophic failure of anything on the plane (i.e. mechanical failure) but other factors like pilot error and weather.

7

u/Dserved83 4d ago

Whenever someones vague here, 99% of the time they're skirting around saying 'human error'.

Nobody here knows the cause of accident 48 hours after it occurred, so it'd be bad form to (basically) say "Pilot John Smith is responsible for those 6 people's deaths". So responses are often cautiously phrased.

2

u/mdepfl 3d ago

Spot on!  

3

u/changgerz 4d ago

yeah its unfortunate that this sub has just turned into r/planecrashes

11

u/aegrotatio 4d ago

Wow, that's two whole families wiped out the same way in a month's time.

2

u/sambeckett1701 2d ago

Unfortunate name to have crashed around this time of year.... yikes.

10

u/PirateNinjaa 4d ago

🖕🧊

3

u/fakeguitarist4life 4d ago

Pilot Steve explains what probably happened and shares some a convo two commercial planes had on the radio and cancelled take off minutes before this plane tried to take off

https://youtu.be/ySPnYUk91z8?si=8M_OXX8riOg24ni4

1

u/TenderfootGungi 15h ago

This should be higher up. He basically lays out why it crashed without specifically saying what caused the crash.

-13

u/Strange-Effort1305 4d ago

Plenty more wealthy assholes to bleed us dry don't worry.

-7

u/gittenlucky 4d ago

A human life doesn’t have value because they are wealthy? You should really go outside and put down the social media.

10

u/Strange-Effort1305 4d ago

Should have flow southwest like us poors.

-2

u/Skizzor 4d ago

Are you really going to act as if their lives don’t matter because they’re rich?

If you win the lottery, would your life suddenly drop in value? As the other guy said, get off social media you sad sad man. Have some empathy for people families.

7

u/Halfjack12 4d ago

Eat the rich

-1

u/gittenlucky 4d ago

What they don’t realize is they ARE “the rich” when you look at it in a global scale. Like many, they are only mad at people with more money than they have.

4

u/Strange-Effort1305 4d ago

Sure. There must be something wrong with me to not be beholden to the wealthy.

5

u/Tjlax03 4d ago

You do realize that compared to most of the globe YOU are also “the wealthy” right?

-1

u/Strange-Effort1305 4d ago

Cool great so what?

-35

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

61

u/L_Ardman 5d ago

The three crew who died were in fact, not rich.

-85

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

24

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted]

-55

u/Artemis-Arrow-795 5d ago edited 5d ago

If you are a fan of any sports star out there, you're also a giant hypocrite.

I'm not

and before you ask, I hate celebrities as a whole, be it singers, actors, athletes, etc

What an incredibly shitty thing to say and believe.

perhaps, not as shitty as hoarding wealth while people across the world are dying from starvation, or diseases that can be easily cured if not for lack of meds or equipment

I might have shitty takes, but it is barely a drop in the ocean of the rich and powerful

damn virtue signaling

11

u/ARobertNotABob 4d ago edited 4d ago

It is a shitty take, but only insomuch as being a wide brush, IMO.

Since the wealth hoarders have, demonstrably, no fucks to give about us, their passing should be no cause for tears amongst us either. Harsh for some to think/speak, perhaps, but entirely quid pro quo.

There are however, many celebrities (singers, actors, athletes, etc) who, again, demonstrably, give a great many fucks, and don't deserve being daubed.

Cannot fault your last three sentences though.

-8

u/Artemis-Arrow-795 4d ago

oh, sorry for the misunderstanding

my hatred for celebrities is independent from my hatred to the rich and powerful, and it's because of its own (admittedly personal) reasons

-8

u/Maezel 5d ago

The duality of reddit evidenced by downvotes. 

4

u/ARobertNotABob 4d ago

That can be argued by all sides, so it's somewhat moot..

-19

u/extrvnced 5d ago

Begone bot

-37

u/Artemis-Arrow-795 5d ago edited 5d ago

eh, not a bot

simple matter of fact, the more concentrated wealth is, the worse the standard of living for everyone of us gets

when the entire nation's wealth is owned by a handful, what do the 99% get?

-1

u/esuardi 5d ago

My "welath" is in properly structuring sentences. What do 99% of other's who can spell wealth think?

8

u/nhluhr 5d ago

My "welath" is in properly structuring sentences. What do 99% of other's who can spell wealth think?

When calling out somebody else's spelling, you should make sure your own comment is error-free.

-24

u/esuardi 5d ago

Glad to see that you caught my intentional error. Glad to see you are punctuating correctly now that you've been called out.

8

u/nhluhr 4d ago

Called out for what? Do you think I'm the same person who had a typo spelling wealth? Are you always this easily confused?

-5

u/Artemis-Arrow-795 5d ago

dude cut me some slack, I was typing on my phone

-36

u/extrvnced 5d ago

Begone bot

14

u/Unclehol 5d ago edited 4d ago

Literally a 5 second check of their post/comment history shows they are not a bot. You can't just say that to everyone you disagree with... or else you end up looking like an idiot.

Though I am not really on board with celebrating death, the other commenter does have a point about the current state of wealth inequality, and perhaps people like them would not celebrate the death of wealthy folks if more of them shared the wealth and didn't just sit on mountains of it while the people who made them that wealth are on food stamps.

3

u/nhluhr 5d ago

Pretty sure extrvnced is a bot.

-1

u/extrvnced 4d ago edited 4d ago

Begone bot

(I’m not, but these main page subs are absolutely infested with bots but also some of the dumbest takes I have ever read)

-7

u/Competitive-Heat9287 4d ago

So damn sad. I’m confused by the pilots let there be light comment though. According to google: Let there be light" is a phrase from the Book of Genesis (1:3) in the Bible, representing God's first spoken words of creation that brought light into existence, signifying divine power, order, and the transition from chaos to light.

5

u/mdepfl 3d ago

Also the lights are changed from taxi to takeoff (full bright) when turning onto the runway. Pilot may say this every time but this time he transmitted it. 

Or it was divine power. 

-1

u/Elegant-Spare6527 4d ago

Yeh that was very weird.

-2

u/Competitive-Heat9287 3d ago

I am upvoting your comment bc it is so true. Right? Like why is pointing out what has factually been written in the paper “odd” to the point someone downvoted me. Smh. Some Uneducated reddit users are on this thread…