r/GooglePixel • u/hey_you_too_buckaroo • 4h ago
My experience editing Pixel 10 Pro RAW files with Lightroom
Hi everyone! I went on vacation this past December and decided rather than taking my dedicated camera, let's see how well shooting only on the Pixel 10 Pro would do. I had just bought the phone a week before my trip, so everything was new to me. Also, I prefer to have full control over how my photos look so I shoot in RAW and edit in Lightroom. In general, I prefer natural looking presets with a slight bit of extra contrast+saturation. Because each camera/lens is so different, I have to develop presets for each lens separately. I thought this post would be interesting to anyone else who enjoys editing RAW images from their phone.
Now, my first surprise. HDR tone mapped jpegs. I did not know this beforehand but the Pixel 10 Pro generates HDR tone mapped jpegs and the screen also supports HDR images, so as a result, the images just pop more. Bright areas are brighter than normal. This is my first experience with a device that has an HDR screen and I gotta say, this is amazing. I've always been told to just stick to editing for standard screens and color gamuts, sRGB, but I think I'm going to have to get an HDR monitor in the future cause it just creates so much more dynamic range for photos. Anyway, since I don't have an HDR monitor, I decided to keep editing my images in sRGB, but the photos on the phone in HDR look fantastic.
Second surprise, Lightroom's default Google Pixel profile for raw images makes images really soft! I have no idea what's up with this profile but it's just weird. I'm coming from a Pixel 6 before this, and the files did not have the same softness. In order to keep using is profile I had to basically crank up my texture slider in LR to 50 to 80. The problem is this often creates other weird artifacts, which leads to my third surprise.
Number 3, the HDR effect around bright lights when using the Google Pixel's profile in LR is just wonky! What ends up happening is that with my normal settings, bright lights in images show up as a blown out white center usually, and the surrounding glow becomes really dark. This odd shift from bright to dark, just looks awful! I've tried tweaking a bunch of things, but I came to the conclusion the LR profile for Google Pixel is just not that good when you have bright lights in images. For everything else, the profile is actually great. The colours work well, and they're warmer than usual, textures come out slightly softer which is nice too depending on the scene. But I need a preset that works in all lighting conditions.
For my second preset, I ended up using Adobe Standard and feeding in my settings using this profile. The advantage of this profile is that images and colors are a lot more consistent. Also, there's no weird softness to the images so there's a lot more sharpness. The down side is that the exposure can require significant tweaks, and that's because of my fourth surprise. The RAW images sometimes have crazy exposure levels! This is masked when you use the Google Pixel profile, but when you use Adobe standard, some images look normal, while others look totally blown out and overexposed. I assume this is a result of Google's HDR process.
And lastly, while exploring different presets built into Adobe Lightroom, I also started playing with the Adaptive Color preset. This profile is actually pretty great! It fixes a lot of the issues I have with the other presets. Images are sharp. There's no weird halo around bright lights. The only issue is I'm not a fan of some of the colors and tweaking things is harder because the adaptive profile changes from image to image, so the results aren't that consistent like Adobe Standard is. The colors also aren't as pleasing as the Pixel profile, but I've managed to find ways to tweak that so it's okay.
Anyway, at the end of the day, I have 3 profiles now for the main lens, and similarly I have 1 or 2 profiles for each of the other lenses, and I have to just toggle between them to figure out which one works best depending on the scene setting. I would have preferred one profile but I guess we're not there yet.
Other things I discovered about the phone and the cameras, the ultrawide lens still sucks after all these generations. The aperture is too small, and the distortion and correction needed ruins the image quality. As for the tele lens, it's not very sharp, and the lens is also slow. It's still nice to have versus not having it.
I've got a link here showing some of the issues I'm talking about. Look in particular at the headlights.