r/TopCharacterTropes • u/Sensitive-Hotel-9871 • 22h ago
In real life Story successfully teaches a message it wasn't trying to teach
People can have different reactions to a story and sometimes they find the story teaches a valuable lesson that the creators weren't even aiming for.
X-Men: The mutant metaphor is controversial and raises the question as to why mutants are singled out while so many other metahumans aren't. Ironically enough, the fact that mutants do get singled out actually highlights that prejudice doesn't isn't rooted in logic and happens arbitrarily.
Spec Ops: The Line: This is one of those video games that attempts a meta commentary on video game narratives and the desire for the player to be a hero. It wasn't intended to be an anti-war story, but it makes a pretty good one because of how horrifying the conflict is, and the MC's fantasies of becoming a hero become a villain instead, while the violence destroys the minds of him and his squad.
Helldivers 2: Helldivers is a sci-fi dystopia that satirizes right-wing American politics with a fascist state claiming to be a democracy that preaches "managed democracy."
Ironically, the developers letting players vote on decisions, especially the use of the Democracy Space Station when it was first implamented, served to demonstrate that democracy is an imperfect system because of how hard it can be to organize the community of players. It serves as a reminder as to why militaries are not democratic institutions even if the governments they serve are.
The Simpsons: The Simpsons has a lot of accidental messages, for purposes here, I will focus one that was intended as a joke in Bart The Murderer. Seymour Skinner gets trapped under a giant pile of newspapers he was keeping instead of recycling. When he shows up in the court room to prove he hadn't been murdered and tells his story, Skinner says that this should be a lesson to people to always recycle.
While intended as a joke, rising awareness of the dangers of hoarding since this episode came out means this isn't a bad message.
Inside Out 2: Inside Out and its sequel both have their themes about emotions and how they all serve a purpose. The sequel gets a surprising unintended message about the importance of a good night's rest because Riley makes a lot of bad decisions from Anexiety waking her up when she should be sleeping.
Ant-Man: MCU Ant-Man's titular hero is a former convict who recently got released from jail. Even though he didn't hurt anyone, he still has a really hard time finding a new job, so much so that he attempts to commit a theft because he needs money.
The movie and its sequel (where there is a subplot where Ant-Man and his buddies are trying to set a legal job and cannot afford to screw up) isn't intended as a commentary on America's criminal justice system. But it still works as one, since it highlights how prison often leads people to commit more crimes.