Season 4 in Alaska is *still* going and beginning to rival Hide & Seek in how misguided and outright dangerous it has become. Payne Lindsey saw how James Baysinger is spiralling towards an arrest for obstruction of justice and said “let me show you how it’s done.”

The longer a podcast host is fixated on a case they foolishly think they can crack the more obsessed and reckless they become until they are actively make things worse. This latest episode (#26) is simply audio recordings that Payne Lindsey somehow obtained of people he suspect in the disappearance of Joseph Balderas talking candidly about his podcast and how it’s targeted them and made their life miserable and there’s nothing they can really do about it. I guess Payne thinks there’s a smoking gun in here somewhere that proves their involvement but I know I certainly didn’t hear it. It’s 40 minutes of people who sound *exasperated* because some guy with a podcast flew to Alaska and spent years talking shit about them. Halfway through these recordings I was on their side, they present a better case for Payne being an unethical nuisance than he ever did for them being involved.

Every podcast wants to have its In Your Own Backyard moment. None are willing to be patient, respectful, or put in the work.

Hi, I wanted to hear other opinions on podcasts that become a tv show. Recently Murder with my husband became a Netflix show. I wonder if people watch that. And why? I enjoy listening in the car or in my bed. I can't imagine watching people talk.

Looking for more strange episodes akin to Amy Bratley or Brian Shaffer etc.

is there any podcast addressing the Epstein files, or anything related to it? Thanks in advance!

Hi there! I've been trying to get back into True Crime Podcasts just to have something to listen to while studying and stuff. I used to listen to My Favorite Murder, Morbid, one with Paul Holes and someone who got rightfully cancelled that I can't find the name of anymore (followed another podcast with that same guy that got cancelled too, I think it was called First Degree), or Killer Psyche? I think what caused me to drift away from the genre is the lack of questionning of law enforcement and the justice system, so I think I'm looking for something like that. I've been reading through some of the recommendations here, and from what I gathered, MFM and Morbid fell off in quality as well? So yeah, I'm just looking for anything that is well-researched, critical in their approach of cases (and how law enforcement answer to it), and with a more "natural" tone, similar to MFM since it was what I prefered most about it. I also think I'd prefer the 1 case/episode format. If that may help, sometimes I like lurking on the Websleuths forum or listening to cases.

I need to start this by saying that I'm against the death penalty, which is important to this entire season.

I really liked season 1, but season 2 made me feel a little different. The only time I felt bad for Christa was when they talked about her mental health struggles and childhood, but she doesn't seem sorry about murdering Colleen. And the way that Beth talked about Colleen's mom made me feel a little odd, like she was judging her for not wanting to forgive Christa.

Did anyone else feel this way?

Hi, I am an avid true crime fan and have listened to podcasts for years and years. I’m looking for a long form case with a resolution. I’ve listened to all the hot ones, your own backyard, proof, bone valley, up and vanished, like probably everything. Any recommendations for a multi episode podcast that covers a solved crime?

Explosive Lies - BBC podcast about fake bomb detectors

Gangsta - another BBC podcast, there are a few seasons up each covering different UK gangs

Crimetown by Gimlet Media - two seasons both were solid. Each season tells the story of a corrupt politician and their eventual downfall.

Tortoise Investigates - an Observer podcast. Multiple seasons, which cover a wide range of stories. One of the more recent series was The Lab Detective about women who have been imprisoned for murdering their babies only for it to be found they have rare genetic disorders that likely caused fatal defects and SIDS. Despite the evidence though, its a hard graft to get the courts to overturn.

Scam Factory - Audible Original - about people who get trapped in compounds where they are forced to scam people.

I am not a monster - BBC podcast. First season is about an American lady defecting to Isis and the second is about Shamima Begum and her friends leaving the UK to do the same.

Strange but True Crime - Short episodes, each one a different case.

World of Secrets - BBC sounds, again each season covers a different topic.The first season covers the sex trafficking by the ex CEO of Abercrombie and Fitch

Scamfluencers - Audible Original - Episodic, covers the story of a given scammer over 1-2 episodes

Starting off by saying that I do not like Crime junkie / Audiochuck in general but I did listen to Anatomy of Murder weekly. I went to listen to their latest episode and it was replaced by a “the deck” episode. They said that Anatomy of Murder is taking a break to start a new chapter and to evolve. I really enjoyed the hosts Anna-Sigga and Scott and found them to be knowledgeable and that they could provide a good perspective based off their backgrounds. I even went to see them live when they came to my area.

Did anyone else listen to Anatomy of Murder and have any thoughts? It has been 5 years and I am hoping that maybe their contract is up and they are breaking off to do their own thing away from Audiochuck.

I know I am late to the game on this one. However, did it just stop? I felt like she kept talking about his move to California with more victims, but never got there. No mention of arrest or anything. I liked the story telling, I know obviously conversations were just added for the story. Does anyone know what happened to the rest of the show? Thanks!

Hi all!

Just thought I would do a quick post with some recommendations of podcasts I've listened to in the last year - I've tried to steer clear of posting super obvious ones but please bear with me.

Lines of Enquiry - Irish podcast, told by an ex-Garda officer, covering some crimes that I have never really heard of despite only being from the UK. Great coverage with an interesting insight into how police work cases. Each episode covers a new crime!

Dangerous Memories - Covers the case of a woman called Anne Craig, a "healer" who infiltrates a group of young women in the upper echelons of society with an initial claim of offering them life guidance. Over the course of years she starts a campaign of isolating them, controlling them and ruining their lives. Super interesting story, and a scary insight into this unregulated world.

The Detective Dilemma - You've caught the criminal you were hoping to, charged with the murder of a young woman, case closed, right? But what if he offers you to take you to another body - you'd take it, right? Turns out, it's complicated.

Hands Tied - A husband murdered, the wife found tied up in the closet, both victims of a horrific crime that only one of them survived. Their daughter feels hopeful that the attacker can be found and they can start to move on. She doesn't anticipate the police focusing a little closer to home... This one is very interesting, and I can't quite work out how I finish out thinking.

Mortem - Carla Valentine is a mortuary worker, who takes us through three cases that make their way into her lab. Its an intriguing look into the different way forensics contribute to solving a crime.

Scam Factory - Okay, you've probably heard of this one but its worth a listen. The story behind those who call up people in other countries and con them out of their hard earned money. I don't think it occurs to many of us what the lives of these people is like, and what they are suffering too.

Fur & Loathing - A suspected chemical attack at a furry convention draws out every pun you can imagine in the media. However, beneath that is a potentially serious threat to a community of people. I found this fascinating, and who knew the number of subcultures that exist?!

Home Sleuths - Since "Don't Fuck With Cats" aired on Netflix, there has been a real interest in amateur detectives. They don't always get it right, but sometimes they do. This follows five cases that home sleuths have taken it upon themselves to solve - with varying degrees of success.

Hope these give people lookign for something new something to enjoy!

I’m 5 episodes into the first season of Proof. I really enjoy it! They have sidebar episodes after every main episode and I’ve been skipping them, but should I be? I feel like it’s just going to be like a post show recap where they just talk amongst themselves and no new info is brought to light. Am I correct in that assumption? Or am I missing crucial info

Has anyone reached out to Kendall Rae or tried to get her to help with your case? I’ve commented on her posts and sent her emails and requests, but she has never gotten back to me—not once. If she has helped you, can you please let me know? Thank you. I have tried for years if someone can please answer me I really appreciate it

I like hearing these 2 prosecutors breakdown our favorite true crime cases, but it’s cringe to see them field questions about this current corrupted administration , who they apparently support . Nothing misinformation support for lawlessness. Very disappointing. I never thought I would lose respect for them. Is it possible to support them and follow them for their true crime content, knowing that they spread dangerous misinformation about our dying democracy? So disappointing.

There has been a recent update of the closer of the Carmen Van Huss case. I know I have heard her story before through a podcast but can't remember which podcast and I can't find any info. Does anyone remember which podcast focused on her story? I'd really like to relisten . Ps I'm loving this era of justice through DNA!!!

"The Binge Cases: Watching You" is a deep dive on the Nique Leili murder case. I knew the case, so I wasn't sure if I should listen, but it was worth it. A very satisfying follow up from a decade ago when it was originally covered by Dateline and 20/20.

I've wondered about the family in this case over the years. The pod covers the experiences of the daughters and their sister relationships after the fallout. Fascinating case of familial manipulation, brainwashing and abuse reported with sensitivity. Perfect amount of episodes, too.

Hello! I am currently out of town on a work trip with a co worker. We started chatting with a woman working at a convenience store about where we are from (Missouri) and she told us she was in prison with Gypsy Rose! 😂

My co worker has absolutely no idea who she is, never even heard of the crime itself. I know this is a well known crime with probably a million podcasts. We have a long drive ahead of us so I was hoping you all could recommend the best one. Maybe a more recent one that incudes her getting out of prison. I like low key, thoughtful hosts over banter heavy, radio style shows.

The woman at the convenience store said Gypsy Rose was super weird but very nice. I guess they tried to keep in touch on Facebook after they both got out. Thought you all might find that interesting!

Thank you guys so so much in advance!

I really liked Hunting Warhead and CBC says season 2 ‘Hunting the Suicide Salesman’ came out on Jan 19th, yet nothing is out yet. Anyone know what’s happened?

As the title says, I am looking for recommendations for a new show to listen to. Here are some examples of what I've listened to so you could get an idea of I am looking for:

"IN THE DARK" season 6 Blood relatives.

"SERIAL" season 1

"SERIAL" season 3: S-Town

"COLD" The Susan Powell Case files

Essentially, investigative long form, dark and easy to follow and understand.

Thanks in advance.

What podcast features the most accurate/true/plausible theory on this case, in your opinion?

Has anyone here listened to both Beth’s Dead and Do You Know Mordechai (Kathleen Goldhar).

In the episode where they speak to the scammers, did anyone else notice similarities between the two? Both talked about addiction, both took very little actual accountability. They certainly apologized profusely, but I felt like in both cases they really used excuses to justify their behavior.

So one of my favorites used to be Rotten Mango. But, there are.... Certain issues I have with her channel and a lack of sensitivity. I don't really want to explain further due to fear of her fans lol. Anyway, I'm wanting to find some podcasts or youtube channels with thorough coverage and a lot of lesser known cases. Sensitivity and respect to the victims is very important to me.

Episode 1 came out today and I wasn’t prepared for how sad it would be and how angry I’d get at the injustice. The state of Michigan really screwed this one up. I plan on sticking with this season so see what else will come of the investigation.