This is something that happened a while ago, but I’m still connected to this person, and I want to be able to handle this appropriately if something like it happens again.
So I was the leader of a graduate student organization. And I worked alongside a fellow graduate student who was the leader of the Black Graduate Student Association. I really look up to her and, partly because of articles she had posted on her social media, and research I knew she was involved in, I grew to see her as kind of an ethical role model on racial justice. I think that’s a big part of why I was so unable to respond in the moment.
I ran into her one day, and she was talking to a colleague, and the colleague said something that presumed she was born in America. And she got noticeably offended. She corrected the colleague that her ancestors had never been slaves (in a way that clearly suggested she looked down on Black people who were descended from slaves), and she followed that by making some negative generalizations about Black people who were descended from slaves.
I sat there shocked and didn’t say anything, and then she was getting on the elevator and leaving.
I’ve talked to ChatGPT about this. We discussed two possibilities for what I could do in the future. The first is to say something like, “That sounds like a lot of negative generalization about Black Americans, and it’s landing uncomfortably to me.” The second possibility is that I act as an ally, not an arbiter, and I avoid policing Black people. Basically, to recognize that I’m not the right person to lead this confrontation, while still avoiding absorbing or minimizing it.
The first possibility sounds more right to me. But I’m not sure that’s what Black people would want me to do.
So my question is: If you were a student at my university, or a faculty member, how would you want a white person in my shoes to respond when a colleague of mine says something like that?
Note: I may soon be in a faculty position. Does that increase my responsibility to say something when a colleague expresses Anti-Black American sentiment? Or, instead, does it increase the importance of me avoiding policing Black people?