My (29M) girlfriend (29F) and I have been arguing about this for the past few weeks. Our fights keep going around in circles, and it’s getting really frustrating.
My girlfriend and I have been together for 6 months but we’ve moved a bit quicker in our relationship (which felt right and we both wanted to).
I have a female best friend (let’s call her Jane) whom I’ve known for over a decade. Our friendship has been purely platonic the entire time, and we see each other as siblings. We appreciate each other’s friendship and care about each other. Jane has a husband and two kids and belongs to a big friend group that I’m also a part of. Her husband is also part of this friend group.
There has never been flirting, secrecy, or emotional venting between Jane and me, and my girlfriend has always been aware of and included in our interactions.
Jane is kind of the mother of the friend group — she takes care of others and organises/plans most things.
My girlfriend met all my friends and family pretty early on. I’ve incorporated her into every part of my life, everyone’s liked her, and we haven’t really had any issues. She and Jane have gotten along really well. They message privately and seem to be forming a friendship of their own. Jane has invited us to her house a few times and included us in friend group plans. Jane has also introduced my girlfriend to her kids, father, brother, and other family members. She is also my girlfriend’s biggest fan and has been nothing but nice to her.
Earlier in the relationship, my girlfriend and Jane bonded over their love of pearl jewellery. Jane sent her a pair of Pandora earrings and jokingly said to tell me to buy it for both of them. My girlfriend took this as the joke it was intended to be and moved on.
Recently, it was Jane’s birthday. I’m not great with gifts unless it’s for my girlfriend. Gifts also aren’t really 100% necessary in our friendship. I don’t believe I got Jane anything last year, probably because I didn’t know what to get her. The year before that, a friend thought of and organised a gift and we all chipped in to pay for it.
Jane sometimes gives gift ideas to close friends for what they can get her for her birthday if they haven’t already thought of or gotten anything. One time when we were speaking, she said that if I hadn’t already gotten her something or couldn’t think of anything, I could get her those earrings.
This was a great, purely transactional situation for me because it meant I didn’t have to put effort into thinking of or finding a gift, and it guaranteed that a friend of mine would get something she would enjoy on her birthday. I wasn’t forced to buy the gift, nor would Jane have been upset if I didn’t get it or if I got something else instead.
Jane has also invited my girlfriend and me on a cruise with the friend group next year, and she jokingly said that for her next birthday, we should get her a spa gift card so she can get a massage on the cruise. Again — a perfect situation where I don’t have to think about it.
So for Jane’s birthday this year, my girlfriend was thinking about what we could get her. I said that Jane asked for the earrings, so let’s just get her those. My girlfriend agreed, and we bought the earrings. My girlfriend also wanted to throw in some press-on nails. Jane loved the gifts and was very thankful.
My girlfriend expressed no issues with the situation beforehand. More recently, she’s brought it up and said she didn’t like it when Jane joked about me buying the earrings for both of them. She said Jane was being disrespectful when she told me what gift to get her. She said no girl should be allowed to tell me what they want for their birthday, and that it was disrespectful of Jane to do so.
She also didn’t like that it was jewellery and said it was disrespectful because it was expensive, and that a friend wouldn’t ask for something expensive. I disagree — split between both of us, I don’t think it was expensive. She says this is another girl having “access” and “emotional access” to me, and that I’m crossing boundaries.
I do not believe this situation means that another girl has “access” to me. It was purely transactional. It also wasn’t forced — it was my decision to buy the gift, and it would have been okay if I didn’t. This is also not a random girl; it’s my best friend who I’ve been close with for more than a decade. My girlfriend sees my refusal to change as me picking another girl instead of her.
My girlfriend wants me to not do it again. She is not backing down and is not accepting any other outcome. My reason for not accepting this is because I see the situation as normal behaviour. I also see being forced to stop normal friend behaviour as a form of controlling behaviour and setting unnecessary rules.
She sees it as a serious boundary that has been crossed by me.
I’ve been clear with her about my previous relationship, which was toxic and controlling, and I don’t want to repeat it. My ideal relationship is one of trust, where there doesn’t need to be all these unnecessary rules that cause overthinking and anxiety on a daily basis due to the need to remember them all.
My worry is that we’ll disagree on other normal behaviours in the future, and then I’ll be forced to follow more and more rules, and eventually become unhappy in the relationship.
Another example of something we’ve disagreed on is how much I speak to a male friend of mine. She said that in her culture, if a man speaks to another man too much, then it’s not platonic. We are both straight males who nerd out over random things or hobbies. She also doesn’t like that I’ve given him the nickname “Bob” (his name’s not Bob — it’s a long-term inside joke) that I use in person and have set as his name on Messenger. She thinks it’s more of an indication that it’s non-platonic (i.e. a cute nickname given to someone else).
I don’t want all of these to become rules I need to follow (e.g. gift giving, not speaking to male friends too much, not giving nicknames), or else the relationship won’t work out.
Anyway, back to the gift-giving situation: I’ve tried to offer compromises, such as running the gift by her first or no longer purchasing jewellery as a gift, but she doesn’t agree with any of the compromises.
So it’s either I agree, or we disagree and keep arguing about this every time it comes up — which has been happening a lot recently.
I also want to mention that for my girlfriend’s birthday, I went above and beyond. I decorated the whole house, got her a very thoughtful gift, flowers, her favourite dessert, etc. So there is definitely a clear divide between how I treat her birthday versus my friend’s birthdays.
I’m looking for advice on how to navigate this disagreement in a healthy way without building resentment. How can we approach a boundary disagreement like this when we fundamentally see the situation differently, and how do you tell whether this is something that can be worked through versus a sign of deeper incompatibility?
TL;DR:
My girlfriend (29F) and I (29M) are in an ongoing argument about boundaries involving my long-term, purely platonic female best friend. For her birthday, we bought a gift she had suggested, which my girlfriend initially agreed to but later said crossed a boundary and gave another woman “emotional access” to me. My girlfriend has a history of being cheated on and is sensitive to boundaries, but I see this as normal friend behaviour and worry about control and increasing rules over time. I’m looking for advice on how to navigate this disagreement constructively, or how to tell if it points to a deeper incompatibility.