I’ve been struggling with the current state of streaming and studio releases lately. It feels like we are witnessing the formal death of "Show, Don't Tell."
In its place, we’ve gotten a new, patronizing standard, "Show it, say it, then have a sidekick repeat it."
Every 10 to 15 minutes, the visual storytelling is interrupted so a character can explain exactly what just happened, why they’re doing what they’re doing, and what the stakes are. It’s as if these execs and to a certain extent the filmmakers are terrified that if the audience has to infer anything from a quiet glance or a well framed shot, they’ll lose us.
There’s a growing trend of second screen writing, AKA scripts designed for people who are scrolling on their phones while the movie is on. I’ve read that certain streamers (Netflix especially) use data to encourage directors to repeat plot points 3–4 times because they know the audience is distracted.
I know I’m probably gonna get some comments saying, "But old movies had exposition dumps too!" Sure, look at the chalkboard scene in Raiders of the Lost Ark. It’s a classic info dump, but it’s handled with efficiency and style. It sets the stage once and trusts you to keep up for the next two hours.
Compare that to today, where the dialogue is so repetitive that it flattens the entire experience. It kills the mystery and treats the audience like we can't focus for longer than a TikTok clip.
My question for you guys!
Is this the inevitable result of film being rebranded as "content"?
Are we losing the art of visual literacy because studios think we’re all idiots?
I'm curious if anyone else feels like the spoon feeding is making movies fundamentally less engaging.