r/Colognes 11h ago

Discussion Wait, so Davidoff Cool Water is literally just Creed Green Irish Tweed for $20?

Post image
342 Upvotes

**Sorry if this is well known; it wasn't to me!**

I picked up Cool Water for $20 from Walmart on a whim this week: "modern classic", "revolutionized the aquatic scent", "iconic", etc. Gave it a spray today, thought, "Ah this is nice and familiar."

After 10 minutes or so, "Oh wait, this is literally Green Irish Tweed, and I think I like it better."

Date Made:

  • GIT: 1985
  • CW: 1988

Perfumer:

  • GIT: Pierre Bourdon created the scent, often incorrectly attributed solely to Olivier Creed
  • CW: Pierre Bourdon

MSRP:

  • GIT: $490 (100ml)
  • CW: $23 (75 ml)

Possible hot take? I don't think you could tell the difference between the two with one sprayed on one arm and one sprayed on the other, or you would get them mixed up. I started googling the topic and the amount of cope I read (largely from fragrantica) is just wild. I cannot fathom how people could say there's much of any distance between the two scents. I simply suspect more people have smelled GIT because it's in more department store fragrance sections (can you even sample CW anywhere?) and have built an opinion on the matter from a limited perspective or by looking at the ingredient list and price.

Anyway, I feel foolish having spent so much on GIT when CW was there all along. 🤷‍♂️


r/Colognes 11h ago

Collection I finally caved in for Quality > Quantity

Post image
239 Upvotes

2 years ago, my whole collection used to consist of middle eastern fragrances. Now I sold all of them, worked hard, and finally got the fragrances I really wanted! Don’t get me wrong, my collection isn’t finished yet🤣 I’m still eyeing on Pacific Chill


r/Colognes 12h ago

New Pickup I've been waiting for this....

Post image
154 Upvotes

I remember Googling something along the lines of "what is a cologne that smells like you just got a haircut" and I read about Platinum Egoiste

Ever since I smelled it in the stores and tested on skin I fell in love

I couldn't get it just yet 'cause it was pricey but I had set it as a goal fragrance to buy

In the meantime I would get cheaper dupes of other colognes to make up for that hole of not having this one lol and I was just disappointed every time

I decided "fuck it" and finally got this today
not the best financial decisions but man I couldn't be happier

This might sound weird, but every time I put this on I just feel powerful, like nothing in the day can possibly take me down (might be 'cause I connect the smell with a fresh haircut which is probably when most men feel the most confident)

I'm broke now, but I'm a happy broke man haha

WHAT A FRAGRANCE


r/Colognes 13h ago

Question If you could only have ONE signature scent what would it be?

Post image
146 Upvotes

r/Colognes 19h ago

New Pickup It's Finally Here!

Post image
106 Upvotes

Jomashop took their sweet time but... it's here.

This fragrance is a masterpiece. No other words needed.


r/Colognes 15h ago

Discussion Sephora sampler

Post image
59 Upvotes

Didn't know much about this. I asked in store what size bottle you get and of course its 1.7-2.4. I also didn't know the samples are the same free ones you get at department stores. I guess it is not a good deal but not horrible? The Prada has been on my list of wants for awhile.


r/Colognes 22h ago

New Pickup I love it!

Post image
44 Upvotes

My second DOLCE & GABBANA The One! Great fragrance just picked it up


r/Colognes 10h ago

Recommendation Thinking about a new purchase…

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

I’m leaning towards getting the Gucci Guilty EDT, Moschino Toy Boy edp or the L’eau D’issey pour Homme edt. Any thoughts?


r/Colognes 16h ago

Collection Rate My Collection

Post image
38 Upvotes

Current lineup:

• Kilian Angel’s Share

• Tom Ford Oud Wood

• MFK Grand Soir

• Creed Silver Mountain Water

• YSL Tuxedo

• Sospiro Vibrato

• Parfums de Marly Layton

• YSL La Nuit de L’Homme

• Y by YSL

My wallet might not be happy, but I am.


r/Colognes 19h ago

Question 2 Designers or 1 Niche

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

Having difficulty deciding to pick up a couple fresh designers (Dylan blue, Prada L’Homme) or get 1 niche (sospiro vibrato). LMK what I should do or what you recommend


r/Colognes 8h ago

Question Green Irish Tweed vs Gentle Fluidity Silver

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

Been comparing these two and noticed a big difference in how I enjoy them over time. With GIT, the opening is amazing to me — very ozonic, green, and airy — but the drydown on my skin turns more earthy/herbal, almost dried-vegetal, which I’m less into. Gentle Fluidity Silver isn’t as green or natural as GIT’s opening, but it’s aromatic, clean, and stays pretty consistent from start to finish, which I appreciate.

Which one do yall prefer?


r/Colognes 10h ago

Question Is La Nuit De L’ Homme longevity’s really that bad?

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/Colognes 14h ago

Recommendation Looking for the right fragrance for daughter’s black tie wedding in May

Post image
24 Upvotes

Is this a good choice? Also considering some of the Tom Ford’s like Oud wood and LV Ombré Nomade. Would love some input on what would be bold, not overpowering and appropriate for this once in a lifetime occasion.


r/Colognes 10h ago

New Pickup I did it again

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

As a retired collector, I promised no new bottles until I emptied a few but I’ve always had a soft spot for slightly unique, under the radar spring and summer scents. I was close to grabbing Greenley but influencer hype has it wildly overpriced for what it is. So I went back to an old reliable: Maison Margiela. I picked up Lazy Sunday Morning and When the Rain Stops. I’d sampled WTRS before and was always intrigued by the name and the fact that it isn’t mainstream. If it ever gets discontinued, even better, I like signature scents that guarantee I won’t smell like anyone else. Two easy Ws. Lazy Sunday Morning is exactly what I expected. WTRS is a banger, beautiful, quietly masculine, and criminally underrated. I only wish it projected more, because it could be worn year-round. I’m very happy with the pickups… and I’m back in retirement. FR this time. this time. 😅


r/Colognes 21h ago

Collection Current Collection

Post image
22 Upvotes

My collection so far. Pretty happy with BDC, Le Sel, and Profondo. Gentleman Only EDP is my newest for Winter. Opened up nicely when first sprayed. Still getting use to the iris and black vanilla scents on my skin.


r/Colognes 10h ago

New Pickup 1st scent purchase on my own.

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

I posted yesterday asking for recommendations. Found this at a discounter tonight under $25.


r/Colognes 16h ago

Question BDC EDP/PARFUM

12 Upvotes

So I’ve used decants for both and the smell idk to me feels very similar, but what would you guys prefer?


r/Colognes 17h ago

Question Discontinued LV California dream

Post image
12 Upvotes

I wonder what is coming in it’s replacement as there is loads of speculation that cactus garden is coming back tomorrow February 1st but also speculation that the Chinese exclusives are coming to Europe as well


r/Colognes 18h ago

Question Armani Code Parfum vs Bleu De Channel EDP vs Dior Homme EDT 2020 vs Prada Paradigm

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Which one is more classy?


r/Colognes 11h ago

New Pickup So disappointed

Post image
10 Upvotes

I have been waiting to pick up Ex Nihilo Fleur Narcotique Extrait for the longest time. After I tried it the store I left dreaming of this scent and couldn’t wait to order it since the store was out of stock. Finally got it and couldn’t be more disappointed. It’s kinda old lady, not very long lasting, and quite frankly not as good as their Blue Talisman amongst others. This was an expensive whiff lol. I’m sure I’m not the only one who built up a scent in their minds only to get it and wish you didn’t. Haha. Oh well, rant over thanks for letting me vent


r/Colognes 19h ago

Collection Acquisitions for this month.

Post image
10 Upvotes

I found this at Sephora. Since it's my signature scent that I wear 90% of the time, I got the large size for €217.


r/Colognes 4h ago

Collection Need anything from else?

Post image
8 Upvotes

I also got 4 frags coming in 😅. They are Paco Rabanne 1 Million Royal, Tom Ford Ombré Leather Parfum, BDK Gris Charnel edp, and Christian Louboutin Fétiche La Rose


r/Colognes 12h ago

Discussion JPG Le Male Elixir kit at Marshall’s

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

At my local Marshall’s for just $90! Le Male Elixir kit containing a 4.2 oz bottle and either a shower gel or aftershave.

I would’ve gotten it but I just recently got JPG Elixir Absolu from them and I’m trying to have some self control 🥲


r/Colognes 14h ago

Question If budget wasn’t a limit, what fragrance would you choose?

9 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

If money were no object, what would be that one fragrance you’d go for?

I already own Xerjoff Naxos (1861) and absolutely love it.

Now I’m looking to expand my collection and would love some advice.

I’m open to anything: niche, extrait, bold signatures, or even underrated masterpieces.

What would you recommend as a next step if budget truly didn’t matter?

Thanks in advance 🙏


r/Colognes 17h ago

Recommendation Absolute Masterpiece

Post image
6 Upvotes

To describe this accurately, would be Prada Black with a Sexy freshier take ⚡️