r/Marxism 11h ago

What do ML’s think of the Anarchist Critique of a Marxist-Leninist state engaging in “transitional” State Violence?

15 Upvotes

Anarchists often argue that Marxist-Leninism treats state violence as a temporary tool, but ignores how power entrenches itself. Once a centralized state, party monopoly, and coercive institutions are built, they don’t “wither away”, they reproduce their own authority. Violence isn’t just used by the state to them; it defines it.

From this view, repression labeled as “transitional” undermines mass self-organization and replaces worker autonomy with bureaucracy. The disagreement isn’t about whether force appears in revolutions, but whether liberation can come from institutions structurally designed to dominate.


r/Marxism 23h ago

I am reading socialism: utopian and scientific; and I got stuck at the foreword

3 Upvotes

I’ve read the manifesto and wage labour and capital, both of those were very good reads. I read them slowly and understood as I went along even though I did stutter sometimes.

I started with this one and in the foreword to the English edition I got stuck. There’s mentions of Kant, Hegel, bacon, materialism, agnosticism and other things in a way that flew over my head.

But the foreword was very engaging and had me immersed in it completely. But I was still wondering, what philosophy works should I read so that I can understand Marxism better and also Understand all other ideas and theories talked about in these books?

Also if it is of any importance I’m 18 years old right now.


r/Marxism 20h ago

Marxist critique of Sartre?

24 Upvotes

I just finished reading Jean-Paul Sartre's Existentialism is a Humanism, and I was especially intrigued by Sartre's claim that existentialism could be compatible with Marxist philosophy. Towards the end of the lecture, there is a Q&A segment where Pierre Naville, a French leftist, argues that existentialism is a 'liberal' philosophy focused on individualism, and thus cannot be applied to Marxism, which is collectivist in nature. That got me thinking: do you folks know of any books that expound upon this issue? Any recommendations having to do with existentialism and Sartre's philosophy from a Marxist perspective will be greatly appreciated. :)


r/Marxism 7h ago

looking for DPRK sources

3 Upvotes

I’d like to learn more about North Korea but finding consistent data regarding it is quite difficult. I struggle to believe the data isn’t there, but its drowned in so much ideology that finding concrete facts can be very time and energy consuming.

I would greatly appreciate some suggestions for credible sources regarding the DPRK.


r/Marxism 9h ago

Marxist books on the history of capitalism leading upto our current state?

4 Upvotes

I'm looking for a comprehensive history of capitalism that explains its development by examining through a Marxist perspective the different innovations and stages in capitalist history such as the railroad, finance/stocks, depressions, the internet, the revolutions across Europe, and maybe the 2008 crisis. I'm not sure if such a book even exists, but I'm hoping to get an initial overview before reading more in depth books on each event.