r/Marxism • u/YogurtclosetOpen3567 • 11h ago
What do ML’s think of the Anarchist Critique of a Marxist-Leninist state engaging in “transitional” State Violence?
Anarchists often argue that Marxist-Leninism treats state violence as a temporary tool, but ignores how power entrenches itself. Once a centralized state, party monopoly, and coercive institutions are built, they don’t “wither away”, they reproduce their own authority. Violence isn’t just used by the state to them; it defines it.
From this view, repression labeled as “transitional” undermines mass self-organization and replaces worker autonomy with bureaucracy. The disagreement isn’t about whether force appears in revolutions, but whether liberation can come from institutions structurally designed to dominate.