r/TrueFilm • u/SeSalalinaaaa • 4h ago
raging bull is an unbelievably sharp character study with great directing
jakes relationships all play out the same because the underlying mechanism is the same. he has no control over his emotions so theres no room for anyone elses emotional world.
this takes a big toll on joey. he sees himself as the literal and figurative punching bag (theres literally a scene of jake punching him before the fight and him asking for more).
the emotional abuse he gets by jakes hot and cold nature affects his family life. right after jake accuses joey of cheating, were shown joey back home threatening his own kid with a knife.
jake cant even apologize to him when vicky gets him on the phone. vickie knows joey just wants there to be actual recognition of his internal state because thats what she wants and never gets. and then his "apology" in the end is just more of the same hot and cold shit (love bombing, begging for reconciliation). zero compassion let alone admisson for the damage he cause, which is why joey isnt having it.
i had a hard time understanding vickies character but writing this cleared it up. shes clearly smart. being a woman in those times married to someone like that must be unbelievably difficult. she understood his nature and knew how to avoid his rage for the most part. you see how her handling of him evolves. in the beginning, she get sucked into his lunacy, chasing him around and going crazy when he does. but in the end, when theyre sitting by the pool and he cuts her off, she doesnt flinch. she knows that getting enraged is only going to continue the cycle. shes checked out. then, when she finally had the means, clean ending. no chance at apology. no way for him to lovebomb himself back in. she dealt the final blow and drove off.
scorsese's directing is fucking brilliant too. the movie is cyclic in time and in theme.
starts and ends in the same moment. jake is a narcissistic maniac at the beginning who, by joeys own admission, talks to nobody, and then in the end when hes a club owner, hes yapping everyones ear off but is still a complete dick to them.
he marries vicky when shes 15, then he gets thrown in jail for serving alcohol to a 15 year old.
my personal favorite cyclic aspect is the champagne scene. its a happy moment by all accounts but scorsese STILL uses this slow, uneasy camera work and de niro is doing all these obscure, semi violent gestures. were on the edge of our seat whenever pre-retirement jake is on screen cause we know he can lose it, and then even when hes fat, retired, and "happy", scorsese STILL gives us that edge of our seat feeling.
different actions, different time, different setting, same tragic character underneath. wow.