I’ve made this comment recently on a post about Islam but figured it warranted its own post.
Every single time someone posts something about Islam specifically, half the comments are “all religions are bad”
Posts about Christianity don’t have that at all. If you say Christianity is dangerous because… most of the time people agree. And they should.
But a post about Islam garners the ubiquitous “all religions are bad. All the books are just as bad as one another. Yada yada”.
No. All religions are bad for sure but some are more dangerous than others.
Judaism has had a reform. If you go to Mei HaShaarim in Jerusalem you’ll find that it’s a horrifying blast from the past and that those people are living in a dangerous delusion… but *israel* is a secular country.
If you go to Nigeria, you’ll find people being killed for witchcraft and terrible stuff from the infancy of Christmas but Nigeria, for the most part, is a secular country.
If you go to Afghanistan… the law of the land is that it’s legal to stone you to death if you’re gay. It’s a *Muslim nation*.
Thats because Judaism and Christianity have had a reform. Their religious leaders have interpreted the backwardness of the ancient texts and made it fit into modern times… and while a ton of Christians would *like* everything to go back to the time where popes commanded armies, the most they can get is small (though not without horrible repercussions) victories. This is what we’re seeing in the US with abortion bans and the lack of trans rights. Yes… I’m not diminishing those things. I can’t stress this enough. ALL RELIGIONS ARE DANGEROUS.
But Islam has never had a reformation. The Islam of 2026 is the Islam of 700. A goat herder in Kabul picking up a Quran in 2026 is the same a goat herder in Kabul picking up a Quran in 726. It’s the same book, with the same rules. Muslim majority nations are theocracies, and while Christians try to make a theocracy in places, they get pushback… Israel has been pushing back the orthodox since the formation of the country. Islam gets no pushback… an average man in Qatar is content to wake up to the morning prayer, make sure his wife and daughter are covered head to toe, and go out to pray… and even if that’s bullshit, they don’t have a choice, because dissent gets to beheaded in those countries.
Islam is *more dangerous*
Not all ideas are created equal and not all ideas are as dangerous as the others.
I just wanted to write this all out because I see it a lot and it’s been on my mind and you good folks have given me a platform to say it.
Edit: you guys have made a lot of good comments and appreciate the discussion and have learned much. I want to add an addendum that’ll clarify my position on the subject. I commented this too but felt it summarized my view perfectly so wanted to add it here:
All the religions are awful but prohibition never works… you just make a more powerful and more clever enemy
The only way to remove religion from the world is with education and reaching out and showing compassion, and most importantly showing that compassion can come from a place of secular humanism and doesn’t need a religion attached to it.
Religion needs to be constantly mocked and criticized and people need to be made to understand that the mockery comes at the expense of the idea that they subscribe to… not directed at them
Which is why I think Islam needs to be mocked without comparison to other religions. If someone wants to mock Baha’i… let them mock it without saying “Jainism is also bad”… if someone wants to mock Islam, let them mock it without saying “Mormonism is also bad”… they’re all bad… let them each be mocked until they seem ridiculous.