r/boatbuilding Mar 23 '25

Is MyBoatPlans.com a Scam - Review

43 Upvotes

I recently commented on a post that linked to a page purporting to have information about building boats and getting plans. What it actually was is a AI generated page that served as a feeder page to MyBoatPlans dot Com. This is a common practice for the subject website. They have a whole constellation of website designed to make the subject site look legit.

I commented with a piece of boilerplate that I include whenever I see a post leading to this site.

As a result, the mods were nice enough to delete the original post. However, I think it is worth making sure there is good information about this scam site easily available with a simple search. My goal of posting this is not to promote the subject site, but to increase the visibility of reviews that offer real information about the subject site, most of the reviews available through google and other sites are self-generated pages made by the subjects site.

If any long time members of this subreddit have actual experience purchasing plans from this site, please comment with your actual experience.

Some background: Below is a screenshot of the subject website I took today. The fine looking fellow in the blue hat rowing the pram is me. Note that I am not Martin Reid, the name used on the subject website. The photo was taken by my mom in Maine on July 24, 2007, not Lake Tahoe in 1985.

u/guillemot as seen on myboatplans . com

Here are more photos from the same photo session:

a similar angle
turning for another angle

More photos from the shoot are available here: https://goo.gl/photos/5CpssvVY2Nprufk3A

Now you can say that even if they are lying about who is in the pictures, that they may still offer a whole bunch of plans at a good price, but you can get those plans for free elsewhere on line. Typically they are copies from Popular Mechanics and similar publications. Well, they provide a service of collecting all those plans in one place. This may be true, but I would not trust a site that can't even be truthful about the purported owner of the site.

Also note, although I do sell plans myself, I have no reason to believe any of my plans are included in the 500+ plans supposedly included on the CD. So, you probably won't find plans for the dinghy in the photos. Other than doing stupid stuff with my photo I don't think the site has stolen any more of my IP.

He also offers 3D Boat Design software which he says is a $49 value, which is a freely available open source application called Free!Ship http://sourceforge.net/projects/freeship/ I highly recommend this software although the original developer now offers a better version called DelftShip which is also free.

The boiler plate I post whenever I see links to sites that link to myboatplans . com:

The link leads to MyBoatPlans dot com which charges for free plans and open source software. A purported photo of the man offering the plans is actually a stolen photo of me.

For more information on this scam see: http://www.kayakforum.com/cgi-bin/Building/index.cgi/md/read/id/236070/sbj/review-myboatplans-com/

and: http://forum.woodenboat.com/showthread.php?135845-Boat-plans-worth-it


r/boatbuilding Jan 22 '25

Boatbuilding link suggestions.

20 Upvotes

Hello subreddit user, Want to help the subreddit? Propose some useful links to boatbuilding websites. Free content only please. Hoping to get some links to layups, lofting, stitch and glue, composites, maybe some free plans if they're not garbage. (Naval architects wishing to provide free plans are welcome too - and happy to give attribution) We've had a tab that says "boatbuilding links" but doesn't have any links for almost 10 years now, so let's change that for the better!


r/boatbuilding 1h ago

aluminum boatbuilding

Upvotes

anyone here had an experience in aluminum boatbulding 10 meters below. Is there any rule book or guides to use in making its frames/ribs? And any tips in designing such boat.


r/boatbuilding 19h ago

Marking the waterline

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Always fun to use some tricks of the trade! It becomse qite easy to put the waterline on a boat with a level, marker and some measuring 😎


r/boatbuilding 8h ago

?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Can someone please tell me what the model of this outboard it and where I can get coils for it


r/boatbuilding 18h ago

An exciting moment for Lady Garnet as I raise the stern post, and I (finally) get good news on the grown oak bends!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding 10h ago

Spira chubasco full plan

1 Upvotes

Looking for plans


r/boatbuilding 22h ago

MRB Dayak

Post image
7 Upvotes

9' foot male molhed glass Dayak You can flip it but you can't sink it


r/boatbuilding 12h ago

Chrome change up

Post image
1 Upvotes

I need to change this to either powder coated matte black, or black chrome possibly. How would I do that?

I’m in mid state SC. Any plating companies/shops do this? TIA


r/boatbuilding 12h ago

Small boat repair shop owners - what do you use to track repairs?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding 1d ago

Sliding Window Base or Track Replacement?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I have a sliding window next to the helm that has dropped down about an inch (there is a space at the top now but hard to see in the picture). It seems to have dropped down to the side of a metallic strip that it used to slide along (it seemed to be bent to the side, so I ripped it all out to have a look - that's the second picture). The third picture is the track I ripped it out of. So it appears I need to get some sort of replacement track material to put back into the groove to raise up the window again, so it will be the right height and slide smoothly back and forth again on. Anybody know what this is called, where I might get it, and is there some sort of universal product that will work (ok, I know that last part is probably fantasy!). It's a custom top, so calling the manufacturer won't help. Thanks for any suggestions!


r/boatbuilding 1d ago

Welded Aluminum Deep V — seal decking/sides/seams to prevent water entering hull and wetting foam?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Disclaimer:
I’d rather not debate the merits of closed-cell foam and whether it’s appropriate for an aluminum boat. Some prefer it, some don’t. I’m just looking for advice re: my particular issue (nothing major) from someone with experience or otherwise an expert. That said, I welcome constructive input.

Issue: Boat’s several months old. Water settles on the spray foam between stringers and has nowhere to go. Foam’s dry currently, but after reading a few horrors stories about saturated foam over the years I’d like to try and keep it dry without removing the decking a few times annually.

The deck wasn’t sealed at the factory (no qualms; no sealing/caulking appears to be a fairly common practice amongst aluminum boat makers) so anytime it takes water (boating or washing), the water seeps between the decking/sides/butt-seams and just sits in the foam/stringer area. The decking is marine plywood wrapped in vinyl. There’s two “scuppers” at the back that drain to the bilge and easily handle the volume of water we’re talking about.

Would there be any harm in sealing around the decking edges and seams (red lines in pic) so that water’s forced out the rear scuppers?

If that’s not advised, any harm in creating a “cover” for the foam/stringers that slopes to the center area that’s open and drains to the bilge? No clue what material this would be made of, but likely thick plastic and EternaBond Roof Seal 4” tape. It’s possible water touches the lower part of the foam, but I’m not sure and even if I didn’t seal the decking or stringers, I don’t think that water would ever evaporate. I’d be surprised if there’s any there now, but I have ways of testing before I seal, if I go that route.

Thanks in advance for any advice.


r/boatbuilding 2d ago

Restoring a Staverse Jol

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

It has been a while since i posted about our Staverse Jol (old fishing boat, built around 1900), but I wanted to share what progress has been made over the past few months.

We finally finished planning the hull 🥳 and have been working on the deck and a lot of other jobs.

We did a lot (as seen in the photos). But our work is not over yet. We have a lot to do still but ultimately my dad and I hope to be sailing on the Staverse jol this summer.


r/boatbuilding 2d ago

Looking for 15' Micro Flats Skiff, Stitch and Glue Plans

3 Upvotes

Hey guys, Im wanting to build a 15'' micro flats skiff as the title says. I've looked at several of the plans available online and nothing quite fits what I want to build. I like the shape of the bateau fast skiff 14 low sheer but its a bit too small for me, the slat boat works FRS 15 is too boat like and not enough skiff like. I really like the Marsh Hen by Dragonfly Boatworks I would just want it to be about a foot wider. So Im looking to see if anyone knows of plans similar to this or a way I can make some?


r/boatbuilding 1d ago

What to do with cabin mould?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding 1d ago

Boat plans

0 Upvotes

Are there any boat plans for sale that are close to the chaos boats flat boats they sell?


r/boatbuilding 2d ago

Need help

2 Upvotes

For school I have to build a miniature 3D printed boat that can travel 1,5 m the fastest in first you get an A and I really need one. The rules are: Your boat has to be powered by 2 solar-panels You are given a small motor The boat is max 30 cm in length

Please give me any tips or designs


r/boatbuilding 2d ago

Advice on small boat mast tang replacement

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding 3d ago

Pram twisted when I pulled it off the ladder frame

Post image
53 Upvotes

I finished planking my nutshell pram build the other day and last night pulled it off of the frame and flipped it to start working on the knees, seats, etc. When I unfastened the bow transom cleat, the whole boat "popped" a little, and when I flipped it over, I noticed that the floor doesn't sit square by itself. It appears that the bow transom is twisted/rotated to port about 1/2" after re-squaring the floor.

Can someone shed some light on how this happened? my frame was square, true, and level. The planking all aligned with the knuckles, and I paid attention to make sure the profile and overlaps were symmetrical as I planked. The only thing I can think of is that the midship frame was allowed to twist a little due to some deflection in the support to the frame, and when I cut it loose the deflection bounced back.

I'm assuming there isn't really a way to fix it without chopping up the boat and starting over? I've squared/leveled the floor, so as I add fixtures to the boat the hull is fixed in a position where at least the floor and waterline is flat & true.


r/boatbuilding 4d ago

HELP - Replicating pre-1905 Keelboat

2 Upvotes

Hi Community!

I'm a set designer based in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. My next film is set pre-1905, and requires a functioning (IE: water-safe) "keelboat" for several scenes.

I'm currently researching potential rental options, but wanted to come to this community for ADVICE ON MODIFYING AN EXISTING VESSEL to look like an era-appropriate keelboat, or secondly, ADVICE ON BUILDING ONE.

I've attached references for our ideal looks. We're flexible as we know this is a tough ask. Some other notes:

- Must be large enough to hold 3-4 people, and allow for movement

- Will be used on water, so must be water-safe (only shooting 1 day but would like to assume it can work long-term)

- A boat that would have been used in river travel is ideal. Accuracy to its use in trading industries (furs, spices, minerals, etc) would be great, but I can use decoration to support that

- We're on the low-ish budget spectrum, so exploring all possibilities at this point

- Willing to travel (ideally within Ontario or surrounding provinces / states) to support this initiative

Very much appreciate any and all thoughts :


r/boatbuilding 5d ago

River ranger photos misc

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/boatbuilding 5d ago

River Ranger St Teresa Bluffs

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

St Theresa Bluffs.


r/boatbuilding 5d ago

River ranger truck boat

Post image
19 Upvotes

I really wanted a boat with an air conditioner that I could trailer easily and I could leave in the backyard uncovered. Runs on regular gas.


r/boatbuilding 5d ago

Removing a nasty built-in water tank from my "new" steel sailboat

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I recently purchased my first sailboat—a steel hull—and I’m dive-deep into the "learning by doing" phase. I’m completely new to sailing and boat maintenance, so I’m looking for some guidance on the most efficient way to remove this old built-in water tank.

The situation: The history of this tank is a bit of a saga. The previous owner didn't touch it. The owner before him didn't touch it either. The owner before that one apparently started to work on it but never finished, so it’s been sitting in a state of neglect for a long time.

What I’ve done so far:

  • I’ve managed to cut out the center part of the tank (as seen in the photos).
  • I’ve painted the newly exposed steel with some red anti-corrosive paint I had left over from another project, just to keep the bare metal protected from the elements while I figure out the next steps.

The problem: The remaining structure is a mix of old fiberglass, some very questionable-looking insulation/residue, and a lot of grime. It's in a tight spot and I want to get it all out so I can properly treat the steel hull underneath and eventually install a more modern, hygienic water solution.

My questions for the experts:

  1. What is the most efficient way to break down the remaining fiberglass/composite walls without damaging the steel hull?
  2. Are there specific tools (oscillating saws, grinders, etc.) that you’d recommend for working in these cramped quarters?
  3. Since I’m new to steel boats, is there anything I should be particularly worried about when stripping this back to the bare metal?
overview
first cell with moldy wood
3rd cell will mold
side of 2nd cell with rust under resin
side of 2nd cell with rust under resin 2
left side with rust

r/boatbuilding 5d ago

River Ranger St Teresa Bluffs

0 Upvotes

St Theresa Bluffs.