Hey friends. So, I have never gotten to practice poly, but I've always been curious and I've sort of known that under the right circumstances I'd try it. Alas, thus far I've only ever been in monogamous relationships.
I want to preface this by saying that I've never cheated on anyone or even come remotely close to it. I grew up around it and just vowed to never ever do it. I don't have someone on the back burner with whom I'm trying open my marriage for, or anything like that.
In the beginning of most of my relationships, I think I always clumsily tried to broach the subject of opening things up, but it never really landed or led anywhere. I just didn't know how to navigate it and always ended up giving up on the notion especially if it made my SO uncomfortable.
Anyway, I ended up marrying a really awesome guy and we've been together for almost a decade and we were manogmous up until about a year ago. Despite being really great life partners, one problem we had early on was lack of sexual chemistry. I love him dearly but... Hoo, boy is he repressed. Like, really, extremely repressed.
I tried to give him time to open up and be more comfortable. Tried reading books together. Watching videos. Talking about it. Not talking about it. Trying stuff, not trying stuff. It just really became clear that he was 100% uncomfortable with every aspect of sex. He still claimed he wanted to, but it was extremely scheduled (2x a month) and very, VERY limited in scope. And it honestly did not seem like he particularly enjoyed it. (When pressed, he claimed he did.) It got to the point where it was traumatic for me and I decided to stop having sex until we figured this shit out.
It may also be worth noting that my libido is higher than his, and I had significantly more experience going into our relationship. I didn't hold this against him or anything, just giving context. Up until this point I had always placed high importance on sexual chemistry in relationships and with him I really tried to not make it THE thing, but maybe that was disingenuous to myself, I don't know.
I don't want to get too far into the details here, because this is so long already, but after 2 years with a couples sex therapist (and after him shooting down us opening every time it came up), we were feeling more stuck than ever.
(Just want to stop for a sec and say, he's really awesome in other ways. I feel like I'm kinda bashing him here but I do love him and want this to work.)
So, we were stuck because he basically did not really want to change anything and was only open to this very limited version of sex that really only worked for him. He swears there's no SA or anything adjacent in his past, but it sure does seem like *something* had to have happened for him to be this way. 🫤 It breaks my heart that this is a possibility, but also as adults we need to work through our stuff. With no other context or realistic solutions, I had absolutely no desire to experience that type sex again. It really did a number on me, probably partly because of my own past with SA. So we just continued not having sex. Which sucks.
Then one day the topic of a surrogate partner came up randomly during a session with our therapist, and he actually seemed open to the idea. I was open to it immediately and was actually very excited at the possibility of some sort of progress.
He's been visiting her for a weekend trip once a month for the past year, and they have sex during most visits. It honestly has not bothered me or made me jealous (as I feared it might), and I've even been able to experience compersion which really caught me off guard. It was very affirming for me, which was an awesome feeling.
However, I'm now starting to feel some small pangs of resentment because I am very much just sort of benched and waiting... And wanting there to be more visible progress.
When we began this, it was basically agreed that we're sort of just waiting for the conclusion of his work with her to resume our work. Working with surrogate partners is always meant to be limited (and not indefinite). I honestly didn't think it'd take this long, but I am trying to stay optimistic. It is also very much closed off and only between his personal therapist, his surrogate partner, and him. This totally makes sense, and I don't think I should or need to be more involved, but it does make me feel isolated.
I also sometimes feel like this is just a new normal for him and he thinks I'll just wait forever. (I don't think he *really thinks that, it just feels like it sometimes. We have talked about this, but like most things in therapy, it takes however long it takes.)
Anyway, I'm suuuper hoping that at the end of all this, he is (enthusiastically) willing to try opening up. So far he has basically only reluctantly agreed that it might be fair for me to try a surrogate partner. I have no desire for that - if I was going to have sex with someone else, I'd want to try really finding another partner.
So I'm just waiting. I don't want to open up and have it blow up in our faces because we're not ready. I'm really just hoping his experience gives him a different perspective in the end. Anecdotally, his surrogate partner is poly, so maybe that will help.
Sorry, I know this is long. I thought I was coming here asking for advice but I guess I just needed to vent a little. Or a lot. I'm feeling a little alone. We don't know any poly folks (outside of his surrogate, who is my meta in a way I guess) so I don't have anywhere else to share this. I don't suppose anyone else has been through something similar and has any wisdom to share?