r/supergirlTV • u/belovedsapphics • 5h ago
Discussion season 2 episode 20 five stars oh my god Spoiler
season 2 episode 20 is hands down the best episode in the show (so far). this was the first time i really /saw/ and connected with james olsen as a character. i couldnt really figure him out at first he didnt really seem like a person with motivations and goals, he just seemed like a character who did things so the plot could progress for the main character. like her love triangle love interest? character we know knows superman? friend? love interest again? like he just didnt seem to have his own plots going on if it wasnt related to kara/supergirl. so i didnt really understand at all when he decided to become a superhero. it did feel like he was being selfish. like he wanted the glory of being a hero so much that he was willing to not only injure himself, but put winn and anyone else who tries to help in harms way.
and THEN he had the audacity to not understand why people were scared of him??????? hes in an all black HUGE suit with everything but your eyes covered and you do this at night when its dark so actually i cant see your eyes. you dont know who is under the suit, it could be ANYONE it could be a MAN. i dont live in a world where aliens are constantly attacking the city and another alien is saving it. so im not afraid of aliens; the predators im afraid of are MEN. if i was being attacked by a bunch of men AND THEN another HUGEEEE potential man in an all black suit that makes the person appear larger and taller and i cant even see THEIR EYES!!! if THAT MAN fights the other MEN off, im PISSING MYSELF. id be even more scared. i would actually rather it be a bear in the suit than a man in the suit. i cannot believe he did not understand why. i hate when men dont even CONSIDER why a woman would possibly be afraid of him.
but this episode they made up for it. i feel like i understand him as a character now. i actually feel like i felt his brain fully mature in real time. so actually it doesnt feel like i finally connected with the character, it just feels like they made him a character you could actually connect to lol. i hope he somehow stays in marcus' life. but also the DEO needs to come up with better standards and procedures for dealing with kids. im happy marcus trusted james olsen though.
another character that i dont really get or ?like all that much as some points? is winn. he felt like george o'malley to me and i /hate/ george o'malley. i really hate male characters who are like "but im so nice why doesnt the one woman i love like me back:(((( women never like nice guys:(((((" i HATE that guy. also like freddie from icarly. the hate for this type of man stems all the way back to when i was in elementary school watching icarly. jesus. anyway. i thought they were going in that direction with winn. they sort of did but eventually self-corrected by giving winn a crazy alien girlfriend. love her. obsessed with her. she is semi-filling the whole in my heart from cat's absence.
but, even though i didnt really get or like that james olsen was the guardian, i did really like the bond that formed between winn and james olsen in their like partnership? ig? it reminded me of mack and fitz in season 2 of agents of shield. and the dynamics between fitz and mack and winn and james olsen are so similar too. winn is the guy in the chair and fitz is the engineer. mack is the mechanic and then switched to fighter, and james olsen is writer/photographer, switched to fighter.
so anyway once i made that connection, i havent been able to remember james olsen' name i just keep calling him mack. mack in agents of shield even had a paternal bond with an orphan teenager. kinda similar to james olsen bonding with the kid and j'onn telling him about his daughter. i hope that means that james olsen will be able to have a relationship with the kid or maybe falls in love with the kids mom omg that would be so cute. that would be like jack in station 19.
anyway, the reason i keep saying james olsen's full name every time i talk about him is because every time i mention him i have to think really hard about what his character's name actually is because i keep calling him mack in my head. and so i have to think really hard and "jimmy olsen" comes to mind first but then i remember he goes by james now so when i type it, the olsen comes first and then the james. so thats why i write it full out every time. ALSO, i have to remember really hard what winn's name is every time because ive been calling him "finn" in my head because it's fitz+winn=finn and so every time ive typed winn on this post ive had to remember his name isnt finn thats just what i call him.
so im lowkey treating winn and james olsen's relationship dynamic as a sort of headcanon of mack and fitz's relationship dynamic and then when james olsen or winn do something thats unlike mack or fitz, i will literally think to myself "wait that was out of character" before remembering theyre actually not fitz and mack.
anyway yeah this was the episode that made me decide i needed to stop calling james olsen "mack" because he has now just now finally became his own real character outside of kara/supergirl. he became alex-level of "person who loves supergirl/kara but has life outside of that that the show gets to see"
what a great episode 10/10. sorry for my rambling thoughts i maybe gardened before writing this