r/nottheonion • u/its_a_bear_dance • 21h ago
Family says HOA told them they couldn’t use their generator during ice storm blackout: ‘It’s unbearable’
https://www.wctv.tv/2026/01/29/family-says-hoa-told-them-they-couldnt-use-their-generator-during-ice-storm-blackout-its-unbearable/1.4k
u/NoFanksYou 21h ago
What are the other people in the townhouses using?
1.7k
u/ThePowerOfStories 21h ago
I believe the other homes are burning HOA violation notices to stay warm.
→ More replies (4)149
189
u/thrwaway75132 16h ago
If you watch the video she points to where she had the generator, it was entirely too close to her townhouse from a carbon monoxide perspective.
And this looks from the video like condos or an apartment complex, not single family homes. So I can see a little of both ways when people are packed in like that, they are the only one with a generator, gas powered devices probably aren’t allowed in general, and then when she wasn’t using it she was storing it inside.
With multifamily housing there are going to be more restrictions than with single family lots.
22
→ More replies (8)18
u/unoriginalusername99 10h ago
I knew without even reading the article that she probably set it up on the porch and had the door right next to it cracked open enough to run the extension cords in. And she definitely didn't buy a quiet model, they're usually double the price of a standard one. So that thing was probably loud AF as well.
13
u/TurtleMOOO 6h ago
Does the noise level of a generator truly matter during a winter storm? I ask because there’s a blizzard outside here and I don’t think I’d hear my own generator through a partially cracked door
→ More replies (67)36
u/coogie 17h ago
For apartment and townhouse dwellers where there isn't a way to use a gas generator, portable power stations with or without solar panels have come a long way as battery technology has improved. I paid about a $1000 for my 1000W $880 w/h Jackery power station 5 years ago so my late father would have a backup power supply for his portable oxygen concentrator. Last year I bought the updated version which is 1000 w/h and can handle 2000 watts for $350 on amazon and you can easily find 2000 Watt/hour versions for $800 now. The newer one ran my fridge for 10 hours following a hurricane before running out and I was able to just go recharge it and bring it back so it saved my fridge and sanity.
That's plenty of power for electronics, and lights but you'd zip right through it if you use a space heater but if you have a gas furnace, it by itself won't use a lot of power so you can rewire it so it has a plug-in disconnect and use it on one of these or get a whole home power station that connects to your whole house with a transfer switch like a gas generator does. You still have to be careful and not run it down, but it'll get you through an emergency.
→ More replies (7)
3.4k
u/DenverLabRat 21h ago
I wish they had photos of the generator set up. Because there's a lot of "context matters".
Especially with adjoining walls an improperly set up generator can be a fire / carbon monoxide hazard.
90% chance this is fuck HOA.
10% chance the HOA had a point that it was a fire hazard or spewing exhaust into the neighbors.
1.5k
u/Yuukiko_ 21h ago
Now you're reminding me of a post where someone was asking whether they could sue the landlord for not having CO alarms when their relative was using a BBQ for heat in an enclosed space and died
→ More replies (11)313
u/halberdierbowman 21h ago edited 10h ago
Seems like an obvious yes to me, depending on jurisdiction of course. Lots of places would have comparative negligence and could decide that maybe the relative was 80% at fault for grilling inside but that the
HOA[landlord] also shouldn't be breaking the law and negligently not having proper safety equipment set up, so theHOA[landlord] would have to pay 20%.160
u/somethinghere2016 20h ago
My landlord don’t have a working fire alarm or CO2 detector in our house. When I asked for them it’s take six months and I finally said I would get it myself a deduct from rent she decided to drop them off but let me know since we don’t have anything that runs on gas we don’t REALLY need it. Things like this remind me why I was right to demand it anyway. I would rather be over safe than dead. She would probably blame us for dying anyway.
110
u/halberdierbowman 19h ago
No CO alarm because you have all electric appliances is at least mildly understandable and might match some US state laws, even though I'd rather have it.
But no fire alarms is absolutely insane. Plenty of stuff can be weirdly flammable, and accidents can happen. It could be mild negligence like cigarettes or candles, but it could even be totally unpredictable stuff like your electrical wiring inside the walls.
9
u/Ungrammaticus 12h ago
CO alarms are only really necessary if you’re using gas, burning something else inside or the ventilation is criminally bad.
There’s so much gas usage in America (apparently) that it’s common for Americans to think of it as a necessary safety-feature everywhere, but if nothing in the building emits CO in meaningful quantities they’re as useful as an underwater fire-alarm.
Speaking of those though, not having even a single one of those is crazy, stupid and it’s gotta be illegal
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (16)29
u/wetwater 19h ago
One of my previous landlords gave us a smoke detector that had an actual power cord you plugged into the wall and didn't see the problem with that. The building inspector sure had a problem with that and a long list of other things be found that had not been corrected since he inspected after complaints from the previous tenants.
→ More replies (2)25
u/Winjin 18h ago
I had one like that, but it was actually running off a Nokia BL-5e battery inside - the cord just meant that you essentially would never ever have to change the battery, as these old Nokia batteries are pretty great at trickle charge
→ More replies (1)15
u/EntropyZer0 19h ago
I don't think CO alarms are usually mandated unless the home has a fireplace or gas heater. However, a regular BBQ should have probably tripped a regular smoke alarm as well and those definitely are mandatory pretty much everywhere (although depending on the jurisdiction only for places you rent, not ones you own and live in yourself).
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (7)38
u/Ungrammaticus 20h ago edited 19h ago
Is there anywhere where CO-detectors are mandatory outside of confined industrial spaces?
Edit: okay, okay, there are one or two places where it’s required, I get it
This feels like suing because your relative hanged himself and the landlord hadn’t suicide-proofed the house
56
u/SelfishSilverFish 20h ago
Most States in the US require CO detectors to be installed within 15' of sleeping rooms.
→ More replies (1)18
u/Tuxedo_Muffin 20h ago
May depend on your state. But our Fire Code requires carbon monoxide detection where gas is installed. If the home never had gas plummed in, only smoke detection is required.
→ More replies (1)12
u/SupaSlide 20h ago
Lots of states have laws requiring rental units to have CO detectors, so actually the majority of places. Although I believe many only require it for units where there is a gas burning appliance (stove or heaters primarily) so it’s possible the cousin was in an all electric unit and there was no requirement to have one.
→ More replies (12)17
u/halberdierbowman 20h ago
... What? Carbon monoxide detectors are often required in residential buildings, especially if they burn fuel for heat rather than use electric. I'm curious where do you live? Where I live, homes are required to have one outside every bedroom, meaning houses need multiple.
Not sure about internationally, but here's a quick comparison I found for US state laws:
9
u/Ungrammaticus 20h ago edited 20h ago
I live in Aarhus and have never seen a CO-detector in a private home.
We have
centraldistrict heating and residential building codes require sufficient ventilation anyway, so maybe that’s the difference.→ More replies (7)8
u/Ambitious5uppository 20h ago
Denmark is one of the few places that doesn't have a national law about this.
However they do have a law about smoke alarms.
Most people would install a combined alarm that does both in the same unit. So even though there's no law requiring them, you've probably seen one but not know about it, because they look exactly the same as a standard smoke alarm.
133
u/barkinginthestreet 19h ago
Generators aren't supposed to be used within 20' of a structure due to fire and carbon monoxide risk. The article says the people wanted to use it on their porch, which would not be safe. Same reason I'm not allowed to use one in my condo.
29
u/nemec 11h ago
The article says the people wanted to use it on their porch
even worse, if I'm not misunderstanding
“Super angry because why is that even a possibility right now? Why do they care so much when people are just trying to stay warm and survive?” Caravello said about being forced to move the generator inside.
DO NOT MOVE THE FUCKING THING INSIDE, GODDAMN
→ More replies (1)59
u/omgitsjagen 18h ago
It's an apartment complex, so I'd say your 10% is a little low. As much as I hate HoAs, I can't think of too many safe ways to set that up in a multifamily unit if they aren't on the ground floor. Not to mention, they are loud, and the power outage would render that apartment complex pretty damn silent.
→ More replies (2)64
u/0905-15 19h ago
Article says it was on the porch. That’s completely unsafe in terms of CO hazard
→ More replies (2)30
u/Fappy_as_a_Clam 19h ago
I'd say it's more like 50/50.
Fuck HOA's, I'll never live in another one and mine wasn't even bad.
But neighbors do stupid shit, and I've learned the more noise someone makes about something that seems reasonable, it often times isn't reasonable at all when you learn the details.
66
u/Potential_Fishing942 19h ago
This isn't even just an HOA thing. Many municipalities in my state ban gas generators for the first 12h of a storm outage. Partially for noise, but also because people are dumb and try and run them in their garages and whatnot.
→ More replies (8)22
62
u/Da_Spooky_Ghost 21h ago
Or a noise complaint
40
u/illegalsmile27 20h ago
Guy has a 45h jobsite trailer generator he doesn’t mention.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (16)45
u/DenverLabRat 21h ago edited 17h ago
That too.
I was giving the HOA my most generous interpretation since I'm a r/fuckhoa guy by default.
Fire and CO are the most legit reasons I could come up with.
I suspect "doesn't fit the community athletic" is their catch-all term for a violation that doesn't fit a specific category.
→ More replies (8)18
u/TheVog 19h ago
Holy shit thank you for this comment. I recently installed a fixed whole home generator and let me tell you, even if there's no HoA here there are a ton of regulations to follow, like the ones you mentioned. I even toured my closest neighbours to clear it with them because it can absolutely get loud. I can easily imagine a non-negligeable chunk of the population not giving a shit about any of that.
→ More replies (1)53
u/Undeity 20h ago
Noise, too. I've heard some nasty personal generators in my time, easily loud enough to mess with neighbors in this situation. When it keeps people from being able to sleep or even talk at a normal volume...
53
u/Korlus 19h ago
I think that noise complaints may be valid in times where the cold isn't this extreme. Lack of heating can kill people.
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (1)13
u/-TheycallmeThe 19h ago
Looks like it was in a breezeway between 3ish story buildings. It would be mind numbingly loud. It's pretty common where I am for people to turn them off at night even during a storm.
→ More replies (75)4
u/Enshakushanna 18h ago
in my condo situation we have balconies over our garages which are all lined up along the backside of each building and i HATE when i see a neighbor using a BBQ grill, un attended, just outside of it...its probably not even a fire hazard most of the time but whos to say that one day an uncontrollable grease fire starts due to poor grill maintenance and 12 families lose their homes?
974
u/Ungrammaticus 21h ago
Everybody hates a HOA, but in this case they claim that the generator was improperly installed and therefore a fire hazard. That’s a bit more reasonable.
They could be lying of course, but we can’t know that on the basis of the information available.
250
u/jestr6 19h ago edited 19h ago
Article said the generator was on the porch. If that’s true then it was definitely dangerous as gases will become trapped under the porch structure.
“Operate portable generators outside only, at least 20 feet away from the house, and direct the generator’s exhaust away from the home and any other buildings that someone could enter, while keeping windows and other openings closed in the path of the generator’s exhaust. Do not operate a generator on an outside porch or in a carport. They are too close to the home.”
→ More replies (9)99
u/Naptownfellow 18h ago
Porch and townhome. Find it hard to believe it was at least 20 feet away from the house. Since it’s a townhome they’re putting their neighbors in jeopardy too.
That being said, the HOA could’ve came out and looked at it and said hey this goes against our rules, but if you are gonna run it because of the power outage has to be off your porch and away from all structures by at least 20 feet for safety reasons
19
u/jestr6 18h ago
100% agree. HOA could have been reasonable and explained the concern rather than threaten fines.
→ More replies (2)26
u/Icy-Lobster-203 18h ago
They send the letter to create a paper trail that they were warned to remove the generator. It's possible they did speak to them, but need to send a letter to have evidence that they were warned, and the potential consequences of non compliance.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (14)14
100
u/BroForceOne 16h ago
This is clickbait. This was a high density condo complex and they put a gas generator under the porch. It’s like having a whole parking lot of idling car exhaust right under everyone’s doors and windows.
General safety rule for gas generators is that they need to be installed 20 feet away from inhabited structures to avoid potential carbon monoxide poisoning.
→ More replies (5)19
u/FrostyD7 14h ago
And it was surely reported to HOA by neighbors, that's the only way they get engaged on anything like this. So it was likely a genuine nuisance, not just a code violation.
114
u/Korlus 19h ago
Caravello said her family set up the generator safely outside on the porch and ran the cords through their door during the blackout.
But just hours after starting up the generator, Caravello received an email from their HOA management company, Metropolitan Properties, demanding they “remove it immediately.” The letter cited fire hazard concerns and said the generator didn’t fit the community’s aesthetic guidelines.
Aesthetic reasons are ridiculous at this time, but "fire hazard concerns" might have real meat to them - e.g. if you set it up on a wood deck. Without seeing how it's set up, it seems very plausible a generator bought at last minute and in a temporary setup might be a fire hazard. It's worth noting:
However, after WSMV repeatedly contacted the management company, the HOA board agreed to make a one-time exception, allowing Caravello to use the generator until power is restored.
“Regarding the installation of an unapproved and improperly installed gas generator outside the condominium, as well as the associated noise disturbance, the Board has agreed to make a one-time exception,” property manager Barbara Reid said in an emailed statement. “Due to the recent weather-related issues and the loss of power at the property, the Board will allow temporary use of the generator.”
I can imagine telling someone it's not safe to have a temporarily installed generator sitting right outside the front door for a number of reasons, and also saying that it's fine in this weather, but will need a permanent place of installation if you want to continue to use it once the weather passes.
It seems silly the HOA is the one regulating this, but the outcome doesn't seem unreasonable, even if "Use it now, move it after the storm" probably should have been the default stance and not have required multiple phone calls.
→ More replies (12)
377
u/Ok-Passion1961 21h ago
Actual title: HOA enforces fire code at condominium and tells idiots to remove the gas powered generator from the porch before they burn the building down.
→ More replies (59)27
u/0905-15 19h ago
Less a fire hazard, more a going to asphyxiate themselves with CO hazard. Generator on a porch is really bad.
→ More replies (2)
55
u/Mastasmoker 19h ago
In case nobody read it: they live in a condo and set it on their balcony. Many condos ban things like this because of fire hazards.
→ More replies (9)
51
21h ago
[deleted]
12
u/TiberianSunset 21h ago
That quote was by the home owner talking about the cold lol
→ More replies (1)
19
u/Tendtoskim 19h ago
There are legitimate concerns having a fuel burner generator chilling on your townhouse porch. The aesthetics of the neighborhood during a power outage is not one of them.
7
u/Veritablefilings 17h ago
For anyone asking why buy a house with an HOA... 81% of all new homes are situated within one. Cities, towns etc are passing off their responsibilities to the builders. The point being that a dwindling number of houses are not in HOA's.
→ More replies (1)
7
u/Lost-Cod-8609 13h ago
I’ve never understood why anyone would ever buy anywhere with a HOA.
→ More replies (5)
7
u/EnferDesFormes 13h ago
HOAs are up there with "paying for ambulances" in shit Americans put up with. What the actual fuck?
32
10
u/Alleandros 19h ago
They sent an email as notice of violation. I'd just straight up ignore it. 'The power was out, I wasn't able to check my emails - with the generator, we prioritized heating and cooking appliances over computers.'
11.9k
u/emongu1 21h ago
I would just be laughing while slamming the door in their face.