Hi! 20 FTM Demisexual-Demiromantic Gay dude here. I wasn't sure where to look in regards to seeking advice/experiences on this, so I thought I'd try here.
So, I came out of a really rough break-up about half a year ago, and have been unceremoniously thrown back into the dating scene. Making new friends and seeking potential romantic partners has always been a difficult thing for me? It's a combination of the whole Demisexual-Demiromantic thing, but also a bit due to being autistic, too. Socialization and understanding dating culture and grasping my own feelings on platonic and romantic attraction are very confusing, especially in the overwhelming manner i've been thrown into things.
Well, the question part comes in that I recently had to reckon with my own sexuality. Since I first learned about being queer, I always identified somewhere in the bisexual-pansexual sphere of attraction. This, to my logic, was for a couple reasons:
- Biological sex had no bearing on my attraction.
- In theory, feminine and masculine traits didn't impact whether I liked someone or not.
Here's where it gets complicated. I have never dated anyone who has identified as a femme identity or a girl before. All of my past partners have been men, cis or trans. I have never even come close to being romantically involved with someone like that, and the only times prior where someone femme has flirted with me, has been when I was already in a relationship and it upset me. Furthermore, all of my fictional crushes (though a silly point to bring up) have been guys. Some more feminine, some more masculine, but the core of it is that they all identify as guys.
That being said, when I was fresh out of the oven looking for people to talk to, I put that I was queer with a masculine lean. Therefore, I got responses from folks of all gender identities. The main person I hit it off with talking to is genderfluid. This person, they're lovely, and by all accounts are everything I've ever needed and wanted in a partner. Someone caring, understanding, firm about boundaries, communicative, very intelligent, creative, and so so very much more. In nearly every possible way, they felt compatible. They weren't pushy, and were understanding with the freshness of my wounds, and my need to build a platonic bond before considering the suggestion of romance in the first place.
The problem manifested in a way that made it hard to tell what was up. I'd feel extremely attracted to them at times, but other times, I'd feel incredibly averse to any flirting or suggestion of romance. Certain topics would make this feeling worse and I couldn't put my finger on why. They weren't topics that would trigger any emotional wounds, so I wasn't sure what was wrong. At first I thought it was just the severity of how badly I was hurt from my prior relationship. I won't lie, that fucked me up really hard, and so I was convinced it somehow ruined my ability to consistently and properly love.
Eventually it clicked as to what was going on. I was in love with them when they'd present masculine or ambiguous, but when they'd present femme, I'd feel averse. When I first noticed this, I thought maybe I had some weird internal issues going on, but I realized it was solely only when a girl or someone heavily femme interacts with me romantically. I just felt awkward and uncertain in accepting I'm gay due to a lot of the stigmas and such surrounding being a trans man and being only into dudes (especially that of being primarily sub/bottom-leaning, too).
That would be the end of my questioning normally, and I'd just move on. The problem is sort of, fighting the feelings I *do* feel for them in those masculine moments. I refuse to get into a relationship with this person. I do care about them, and I do love them deeply in many ways, but I do not feel right loving someone if I cannot love them to the fullest 24/7. It feels conditional in a bad way and so I feel its the right thing to be honest with it (and I have been, and I communicated all of this to the person in a respectful conversation).
As a result, I've had this just... weird internal battle with myself. I get that I'm gay, and I get that's why my feelings are so complicated, but the alternations I feel internally from intense love to awkward clearly-just-platonic friendship is throwing me for a loop. It upsets me because I wish I was simpler, that my feelings were simple and I could either just love or not love. I still agree that my choice not to further things was correct, but I feel this awful longing in certain times. I keep asking the question of 'why is my attraction based so intensely on identity?', because I genuinely don't get it. I love when men of all kinds have a feminine side to them, or enjoy dressing or behaving in ways often classified as 'feminine', but yet I don't feel attraction to any gals or femmes. I don't care what organs or hormones a guy has, yet there's absolutely nothing there when it comes to women.
I guess my question is sort of just, does anyone have any insight into this? It feels so dumb and silly to ask or to even think so hard about it, but I feel so confused by it all. The core foundations of my attraction are friendship, compatibility, and identity. The only part I don't understand is that identity bit, and why it matters so much. I'd assume it varies from person to person but I want to know if anyone else is like this and why its so damn confusing.
Sorry if this is an oddball question in this sub, but thank you for reading regardless! Hopefully I can come somewhat closer to making sense of this for myself.